top of page

the mag7 & novo nordisk

MAG7

Revenues & gross margins

Margins Mag7 01.jpeg

30-Jul-2023. GOOGL, MSFT, TESLA, AAPL, META: Revenue & gross margin Comparison of revenue volume (TTM - trailing twelve months) and TTM YoY revenue growth, as well as gross margin on sales (i.e. gross profit / revenue) - see charts... Tesla is the smallest company (volume of sales), but also the fastest growing with revenue growth of 40% - so it is a typical growth company. The remaining companies are rather difficult to classify as classic growth companies (they are too big and mature), where TTM revenues grow around 0% (Apple, Meta), and 4-7% (Microsoft, Alphabet). It can even be said that these are already cyclical companies, where the increase in revenues largely depends on the growth of the entire economy… What is interesting, however, is the profitability of business measured by the gross margin, which ranges from 18% (Tesla) to as much as 81% (Meta). Meta with such a profitable business can aggressively finance new product lines that generate approximately $4 billion in operating loss per quarter.

Margins Mag7 02.jpeg
Margins Mag7 03.jpeg

Revenue vs nominal GDP

Nominal GDP Mag7 01.jpeg

31-Jul-2023. GOOGL, MSFT, TESLA, AAPL, META: revenue growth vs nominal US GDP growth On the trailing 12 month basis (see chart 1), in Q2 2023 only Tesla's revenue is growing faster than nominal GDP. Below the increase in YoY revenues in Q2 for individual companies: Tesla: +40,0% Nominal US GDP: +7,5% Microsoft: +6,9% Alphabet: +4,1% Meta Platforms: +0,9% Apple: -1,17% (assuming 80,9 bln USD of revenues in Q2). Nevertheless, it should be remembered that in 2021 the revenues of these companies grew up like a weed after the pandemic stimuli, so it is also worth comparing the increase in cumulative revenues from Q4 2019 (see chart 2): Tesla: +238% Alphabet: +62% Microsoft: +52% Meta Platforms: +52% Nominal US GDP: +24% Apple: -12% (assuming 80,9 bln USD of revenues in Q2). Apple looks particularly uninteresting, although one should remember about strong seasonality here, and that the strongest quarter is Q4, not Q2, so we are not directly comparing apples to apples :), but even if we compare YoY growth for quarterly revenues (see chart 3), Q2 2023 will be the 7th quarter in a row for Apple with sales growth lower than the nominal growth of US GDP.

Nominal GDP Mag7 02.jpeg
Nominal GDP Mag7 03.jpeg

Does Mag7 trade implodes?

Mag7 Implodes 01.jpeg

29-Oct-2023. The Mag7 trade implodes? Over the weekend, you can read a little about changing sentiment and narrative regarding the Mag7, which boosted the entire market this year. And while the Mag7 dropped more than the S&P500 in the last two weeks (however in the last week it dropped even less than the S&P500), looking from the beginning of the current correction (31-Jul-2023), the Mag7 index still outperforms the S&P500 - see chart 1. How individual companies behave during this period... see chart 2. Microsoft and Amazon, after strong Q3 results, have fallen only slightly and so far uphold the entire Mag7 club. Of course, looking at the returns since the beginning of the year (Chart 3), a larger correction/mean-reversion for the Mag7 club could certainly be due. Links to Amazon Q3 results: https://lnkd.in/dwYvqqqn https://lnkd.in/dswAUziN Link to Microsoft Q3 results: https://lnkd.in/dN7w4555

Mag7 Implodes 02.jpeg
Mag7 Implodes 03.jpeg

Nifty Seven / Nifty Eight

Nifty Fifty 1-Nov.jpeg

1-Nov-2023. Nifty Seven. Nifty Eight. Nifty Fifty. -4.14% is how much the S&P500 Equal-weights fell in October (-3.84% from the beginning of the year). However, the largest companies are doing much better: 1) Nifty Seven (aka The Magnificent 7) in October -0.34% and +60.35% in 2023, YTD (market-cap weights) in October -2.86% and +79.06% in 2023, YTD (equal weights) 2) Nifty Eight (aka The Enormous 8 - Mag7 + Netflix) in October -0.14% and +60.22% in 2023, YTD (market-cap weights) in October -1.26% and +74.62% in 2023, YTD (equal weights) 3) Nifty Fifty (aka S&P500 Top 50) in October -1.41% and +21.25% in 2023, YTD (market-cap weights) After the fantastic results for Q3 2023, the best returns in October were Microsoft (+7.08%), Amazon (+4.70%), and Netflix (+9.03%). Tesla reported poor results (-19.73% in October). What is missing? Apple (tomorrow) and Nvidia results (21-Nov-2023). In Apple's case, disappointment may come from relatively lower sales in China. In the case of Nvidia, expectations are high regarding results, and for example AMD after reporting Q3 result (despite good results for Q3) scared a little bit the market with the too low revenue guidance for Q4 (approximately $6.1 billion, plus or minus $300 million which was below the Wall Street estimate of $6.4BN).

mag7+, Q3 2023 rundown

mag wrap2 Q3.PNG

6-Nov-2023. The Mag7+ short wrap-up of Q3 results. Of the 7 companies, only Tesla failed to beat Wall Street's revenue growth expectations. All companies beat the EPS forecast (Amazon by as much as 62%). With revenues of $143B per quarter, Amazon can grow at a rate of +12.6%! The table shows details about revenues and EPS, as well as how the price of a given company behaved after the announcement of Q3 results. Tesla disappointed the most, while Amazon was the best performer (see also the chart). Based on Factset data (as of November 3), here are Q3 results for the entire S&P500 (for companies that have already reported): 1) the blended (combines actual results for companies that have reported and estimated results for companies that have yet to report) earnings growth for the third quarter is 3.7% 2) the blended revenue growth rate for the third quarter is 2.3% So, The Mag7+ are performing much better than the S&P500 with average earnings growth +62%, and average revenue growth +13,8%.

mag wrap1 Q3.PNG

the mag7 YTD returns

Mag ytd 1.jpeg

4-Dec-2023. The Mag7. 2023 YTD return. Of course, all seven companies beat the S&P500. The highest return since the beginning of the year is Nvidia +211%. The weakest Apple +46%. S&P500 only +19%. Figure 1. In October, the highest Microsoft +7.1%. The weakest is Tesla -19.7%. S&P500 -2.2%. In November, the highest was Tesla +19.5%. The weakest is Alphabet +6.8%. S&P500 +8.9%. Returns for the last two months combined (October + November): the highest Microsoft +20.0%. The weakest is Tesla -4.1%. S&P500 +6.5%. Figure 2. In the case of Microsoft, the last two months returns are the result of great results for Q3 2023 (link to earnings review below text). Similarly in the case of Tesla, poor Q3 results are making themselves felt... (link to earnings review below text).

Mag ytd 2.jpeg

relative to S&P500 (q3 2023)

Q3 Q4 earnings kopia.jpg
Q3 earnings kopia.jpg

8-Dec-2023. Mag7 & Novo Nordisk. How do companies from the Mag7 club behave after the publication of results for Q3 2023? On average, neutral relative to the S&P500 (see the chart). 3 companies are above the S&P500 (Amazon, Microsoft, Apple), the rest are below. Yesterday, Alphabet rose 5.3% after announcing the launch of the new Gemini AI model (and here are the first tests of the model, including with a blue rubber duck: link below the text). Revenues for the entire S&P500 increased by 2.4% YoY in Q3, and EPS by 4.8%. In the table below the graph, I also include Wall Street's expectations for Q4 2023 earnings. Revenue dynamics in Q4 is expected to increase for Alphabet, Microsoft, Apple and Nvidia. The dynamics of profits (EPS) is expected to increase in Alphabet, Meta, Amazon and Novo Nordisk. On the subject of AI... Nvidia's revenues are expected to grow by ... 230% YoY and EPS by 410%. For the entire S&P500, revenues are expected to increase by 3.1% in Q4 and profits by 3.0%.

23-Oct-2023. Mag7+ How do individual companies perform after the publication of Q3 2023 earnings? From the date of publication to the closing price on November 22, 2023... the top outperformer is Amazon (+12.56% relative to the S&P500, and nominally +22.7%). Tesla is the weakest (-9.1% relative to the S&P500, and nominally -3.49%).

relative to S&P500 (q4 2023)

8-Dec-2023. Counting from the earnings publication for Q4 2022 (Tesla started the season on January 25, 2023), all companies from the Mag7 club, as well as the largest European company Novo Nordisk, beat to date the S&P500 (Figure 1), the most: Nvidia nominally +128.9% and +109.6% relative to the S&P500, Meta nominally +117.3% and +105.5% relative to the S&P500, Tesla nominally +68.8% and +54.2% relative to the S&P500, and the weakest: Alphabet nominally +25.3% and only +15.1% relative to the S&P500. Similarly, since the result publication for Q1 2023, all companies have also beaten the S&P500 (Figure 2). After the publication of Q2 2023 earnings, 4 companies beat the S&P500, 2 are neutral and 2 worse than the S&P500 (all calculations at prices as of December 8, 2023). After the publication of results for Q3 2023, only 3 companies have beaten the S&P500, the remaining 5 are behaving worse than the S&P500. If on January 25 we bought 7 companies from the Magnificent 7 club (in equal weights), our portfolio would earn 77.6% by December 8 (bottom panel of Figure 1). If we had a more conservative approach and bought according to weights depending on the capitalization of a given company (the largest is Apple, the smallest is Tesla), we would earn 65.2%. Historically, outperformance and higher valuations of the largest companies (aka nifty-fifty) lasted for years. Of course, after such increases, these companies now have a higher beta and can easily fall more than the S&P500 (e.g. the decline in October of the Mag7 (equal weights) was 2.9% (S&P500 -2.2%), but the rebound in November: Mag7 +11.9% and S&P500 +8.9%.

Mag1.jpeg
Mag2.jpeg

Alphabet Q2 2023 review

Google Q2 2023 1.jpeg

26-Jul-2023. Alphabet (Google) delivered very strong results for Q2, which at the same time turned out to be well above Wall Street expectations, so the share price is now 6-7% above yesterday's close (pre-market). In Q2, +4.4% YoY revenue growth was expected, and it was +7.1% (+ USD 4.9 bln)! The main contributors to revenue growth are Google Search (+4.8% YoY, +1.9 bln USD), Google Cloud (+28.0% YoY, +1.8 bln USD), and Google Other (+24.2% YoY, +$1.6 bln USD). Google Other are mainly YouTube nonadvertising revenues, primarily from subscription growth in YouTube Music, Premium, and YouTube TV, followed by growth in hardware revenues. The result conference call was mainly about AI. In virtually every aspect of business, the company can use / or already uses AI. Sundar Pichai, CEO: “At I/O (annual developer conference), we shared how we are making AI helpful for everyone in four important ways. First, improving knowledge and learning (…) we intuitively know how to incorporate AI into our products (…). This quarter saw our next major evolution with the launch of the Search Generative Experience, or SGE, which uses the power of generative AI to make Search even more natural and intuitive (…) Ads will continue to play an important role in this new search experience . Many of these new queries are inherently commercial in nature. Second, we are helping people use AI to boost their creativity and productivity. One example is Bard, our experiment in conversational AI. Since launching in March, it continues to get better. Third, we are making it easier for others to innovate using AI. One way is by providing Google Cloud's high-performance infrastructure, optimized for a range of generative AI models. Finally, we are making sure we develop and deploy AI technology responsibly.”

Google Q2 2023 2.jpeg
Google Q2 2023 3.jpeg
Google Q2 2023 4.jpeg

Alphabet Q3 2023 preview

googl 2.PNG

24-Oct-2023. Alphabet. Q3 2023 earnings (short) preview. Today, after the market close, Alphabet will publish Q3 2023 earnings. Publishing its results for Q2 in July this year, Alphabet surprised Wall Street in a strongly positive way (+3% sales surprise and +9.1% EPS surprise). As a result of such earnings, Alphabet's stock performed the best of all Mag7 companies since the publication of Q2 results - Alphabet beat the S&P500 by as much as 19.4% - see chart 1. From 25-Jul-2023 to 23-Oct-2023: Alphabet +11.7%, S&P500 -7.7%, so Alphabet relative to S&P500 +19.36% (corresponding to S&P500 at the level of 5033.67 on October 20 - see chart 1). What are analysts' expectations regarding Q3 results: Revenue: $75.99 bln (+9.98%, was $69.09 bln in Q3 2022) – see chart 2. EPS: 1.45 (+38.8%, was 1.06 in Q3 2022).

googl 1.PNG

Alphabet Q3 2023 review

google 3.PNG

25-Oct-2023. Alphabet. Earnings Q3 2023 review. Alphabet generally beat revenue expectations on every line except its Google Cloud segment: 1) Total Revenue: $76.69 bln (+0.92% Sales surprise, chart 1), 2) Revenue ex-TAC: $64.05 bln (+1.60% Sales surprise, chart 2), TAC – Traffic Acquisition Costs: the portion of revenues shared with Google’s partners and amounts paid to distribution partners and others who direct traffic to the Google website, 3) Google Cloud: $8.41 bln (-2.21% Sales surprise, chart 3). Google Cloud has been the key catalyst behind the company's growth on the back of its strengthening cloud service offerings. And this is a market segment with stiff competition. So negative surprise here is hurting. Google's cloud offerings include Google Cloud Platform and Google Workspace. 4) EPS $1.55 per share (+6.90% beat). So at this moment Alphabet is down 6.1% in after-hours trading.

google 2.PNG
google 1.PNG

25-Oct-2023. Alphabet. Earnings Q3 2023 review. Part 2. If lower-than-expected revenue growth in the Google Cloud segment resulted in a decline in the stock price (in after-hours), it is worth checking how it was commented during the earnings conference. And there were questions about the slowdown in this segment. Sundar Pichai, CEO: “ (…) On Cloud, maybe what I would say is, overall, we had definitely started seeing customers looking to optimize spend. We leaned into it to help customers given some of the challenges they were facing. And so that was a factor. But we are definitely seeing a lot of interest in AI. There are many, many projects underway now, just on Vertex alone, the number of projects grew over 7x. And so we see signs of stabilization, and I'm optimistic about what's ahead”. Ruth Porat, CFO: “Turning to the Google Cloud segment. Revenues were $8.4 billion for the quarter, up 22%. GCP (“Google Cloud Platform”) revenue growth remained strong across geographies, industries and products, although the Q3 year-on-year growth rate reflects the impact of customer optimization efforts. Google Workspace also delivered strong revenue growth, primarily driven by increases in average revenue per seat. Google Cloud had operating income of $266 million, and the operating margin was 3%.” “(…) as it relates to Cloud, as Sundar said, what we're really excited about is the revenue growth does reflect healthy customer adoption across the portfolio, and that's infrastructure, data analytics, security. And so we’re -- I can't comment on others, but we feel good about where we're sitting here and looking forward, and we'll let you do the forecasting. DCP growth in the third quarter was above the growth rate for Cloud overall, and we feel really good about the work that they're doing there. And then, of course, in addition to that is all of the contribution from Google Workspace.”

Alphabet Q1 2024 review

Google 3D.png

29-Apr-2024. Alphabet Q1 2024 earnings review My key takeaways: 1) Alphabet rose by more than 10% after the results announcement to a new all-time high. The results were very good and practically beat expectations across the board: +1.9% beat – Total Revenues of $80.54 billion (expected $79.0 billion), Figure 1, +2.6% beat – "Google Search & Others" revenues at the level of $46.16 billion (expected $45.0 billion), Figure 2, +4.7% beat – "YouTube Ads" revenues of $8.09 billion (expected $7.73 billion), Figure 3, +2.5% beat – "Google Advertising" revenues of $61.66 billion (expected $60.18 billion), Figure 4, +2.1% beat – "Google Cloud" revenues of $9.57 billion (expected $9.37 billion), Figure 5, 2) The main threat to Aplhabet is a possible change in users' preferences in using search engines and replacing them with popular AI chatbots that answer questions rather than provide links to other websites. Today, this threat is not visible in numbers, but the success of integrating the search engine with AI tools will be crucial here. Sundar Pichai, CEO: „AI innovations in Search are (…) perhaps the most important point I want to make. We have been through technology shifts before - to the web, to mobile and even to voice technology. Each shift expanded what people can do with Search and led to new growth. We are seeing a similar shift happening now with generative AI. (…) now, we’re starting to bring AI overviews to the main search results page. We are being measured in how we do this, focusing on areas where gen AI can improve the Search experience, while also prioritizing traffic to websites and merchants. (…) based on our testing, we are encouraged that we are seeing an increase in Search usage among people who use the new AI overviews, as well as increased user satisfaction with the results”. On SGE (search generative experience) and Search: “ (…) we are seeing early confirmation of our thesis that this will expand the universe of queries where we are able to really provide people with a mix of factual answers, linked to sources across the web and bring a variety of perspectives, all in an innovative way. And we have been rolling out AI overviews in the U.S. and U.K., trying to mainly tackle queries, which are more complex where we think SGE will clearly improve the experience.” 3) Alphabet showed good results in the Cloud segment, where YoY growth accelerated to 28% (+$2.12 billion YoY). Google Cloud generates revenues primarily from consumption-based fees and subscriptions received for Google Cloud Platform services, Google Workspace communication and collaboration tools, and other enterprise services. 4) Alphabet also showed a large CAPEX (purchases of property and equipment) in Q1 in the amount of $12.12 billion (expected $10.2 billion), but this did not disturb investors (in the case of Meta, the large CAPEX was cited as a negative factor). Additionally, full-year run-rate CAPEX will be at least at the Q1 level or higher, i.e. >$48 billion in 2024 (expected $43.1 billion). 5) To maintain good investor sentiment, Alphabet also announced the initiation of a cash dividend program, and declared a cash dividend of $0.20 per share that will be paid on June 17, 2024. The company intends to pay quarterly cash dividends in the future, subject to review and approval by the company's Board of Directors in its sole discretion. Additionally, Alphabet's Board of Directors authorized the company to repurchase up to an additional $70.0 billion of its Class A and Class C shares.

Google 1.PNG
Google 2.PNG
Google 3.PNG
Google 4.PNG
Google 5.PNG

Amazon Q2 2023 review

Amazon Q2 1.jpeg

5-Aug-2023. Amazon Q2 2023 results. Key takeaways: 1) Amazon definitely beat market expectations regarding revenue growth, YoY revenue increased by +10.8% in Q2 2023 (market expected +8.6%), additionally, the company forecasts revenue growth in Q3 of +10.5% (and the market expected only +8.8%) 2) The AWS (Amazon Web Services) segment showed revenue growth of +12.2% YoY (market expected +10.0%). This is an important segment, investors feared a larger decline in sales here due to customers still cutting IT costs - but this segment has stabilized since May and there is no further slowdown. In Q1, AWS grew 16%, but during the earnings conference, the company reported a decrease in AWS sales growth by 5 points down in April 2023 alone - which caused Amazon's share price to fall. The good news is that in Q3 we can expect a continuation of the trend from Q2. CFO, Brian Olsavsky: “(…) April was running about 500 basis points lower than Q1. What we've seen in the quarter is stabilization and you see the final 12% growth. (…) So, while that is 12%, there's a lot of cost optimization dollars that came out and a lot of new workloads and new customers that went in. (…) What we're seeing in the quarter is that those cost optimizations, while still going on, are moderating, and many maybe behind us in some of our large customers. And now we're seeing more progression into new workloads, new business. So, those balanced out in Q2. We're not going to give segment guidance for Q3. But what I would add is that we saw Q2 trends continue into July. So, generally feel the business has stabilized.” 3) Amazon delivered further improvement in retail margins in Q2 with “North America” segment operating margin up for 5th consecutive quarter and “International” segment up for 3rd quarter in a row 4) As for AI monetization, it will be rather slow… CEO Andy Jassy: “I think when you're talking about the big potential explosion in generative AI, which everybody is excited about, including us, I think we're in the very early stages there. We're a few steps into a marathon in my opinion. I think it's going to be transformative, and I think it's going to transform virtually every customer experience that we know. But I think it's really early. I think most companies are still figuring out how they want to approach it. They're figuring out how to train models. They want to -- they don't want to build their own very large language models. They want to take other models and customize it and services like (Amazon) Bedrock enable them to do so. But it's very early, and so I expect that will be very large, but it will be in the future.”

Amazon Q2 2.jpeg
Amazon Q2 3.jpeg
Amazon Q2 4.jpeg

Amazon Q3 2023 review

Amazon 10.PNG

28-Oct-2023. Amazon. Q3 earnings review. The day after the results were published, Amazon's price jumped +6.8% nominally and +7.31% relative to the S&P500. These are the second quarterly results in a row that were very well received by investors. Since the announcement of the results for Q2 (3-Aug-2023), Amazon's price is +7.6% relative to the S&P500 (and nominally -0.91%), see chart 1 and 2. My two key takeaways on Q3 2023 earnings, a kind of “big picture” to memorize: 1) Revenue beat, both just reported Q3 and Q4 2023 revenue guidance 2) All operational margins up! Additionally what’s also important: 3) In minus, a bit lower AWS (Amazon Web Services) revenues 4) In plus, nicely growing Advertising business segment 5) Of course, strong EPS beat and free cash flow 6) And more positive news about Generative AI (during earnings conference call) Re. 1) Amazon reported Q3 Total Revenue of $143.08 billion (+0.97% beat of Wall Street estimate), which gives an annual change of +12.6%. The company forecasts revenues in Q4 in the range of $160-167 billion, Wall Street expected $157 billion (beat +1.9% to +6.4%), chart 3. Re. 2) All operating margins increased YoY and sequentially quarter over quarter. Gross margin increased +286 bps YoY. See chart 4. Brian Olsavsky (CFO) during conference call on North America segment profitability: “North America operating income was $4.3 billion, an increase of $4.7 billion year over year, resulting in an operating margin of 4.9%, up 100 basis points quarter over quarter (…) The third quarter marked the second full quarter of regionalization within the U.S., and we're pleased with the early results. Regionalization has allowed us to simplify the network by reducing the number of line-haul lanes, increasing volume within existing line-haul lanes and adding more direct fulfillment center to delivery station connections. We have also been focused on optimizing inventory placement in a new regionalized network, which when coupled with the simplification mentioned earlier, is helping contribute to an overall reduction in cost to serve. Additionally, in the quarter, we saw benefits from lower inflation, primarily within line haul, ocean and rail shipping rates, which were partially offset by higher fuel prices” And on International segment: “In international, we were closer to breakeven during the quarter with an operating loss of $95 million. This was an improvement of $2.4 billion year over year. This improvement was primarily driven by lowering our cost to serve through higher productivity, decreased inflationary pressures and improvements in leverage across our established and emerging international countries” And on AWS (Amazon Web Services): “Our operating margin for the quarter was 30.3%. This is an improvement of approximately 600 basis points quarter over quarter, primarily driven by increased leverage on our headcount costs.”

Amazon 11.PNG
Amazon 12.PNG
Amazon 13.PNG
ama 1.PNG

28-Oct-2023. Amazon. Q3 earnings review. Part 2. What was a minor disappointment in the Q3 results was that AWS's cloud segment revenues grew below expectations (although the negative surprise was only 0.3%) - see chart 1. And this segment also contains all of the future artificial intelligence growth. Maybe the revenue miss was small, but if we look at the growth in this segment over the last 4 quarters and compare it to the growth of Microsoft's Intelligent Cloud... so Amazon is slightly behind Microsoft, see chart 2 (in Q3 2022, Amazon's revenues were $213m higher than Microsoft's ones - and in Q3 2023 Microsoft's revenues are $1.2b higher). My key takeaways: 1) Based on the company's comments during the earnings call and general optimism surrounding AWS's prospects, AWS's current slower revenue growth may look like a "temporary blip", 2) AWS's very good prospects should be looked at in two dimensions: (i) "cloud is early" and (ii) "generative AI is very early" - that is, not only generative AI is at an early stage of development, but also cloud... (despite that today's "run rate" of this business for Amazon is $92 billion per year), 3) The development of Generative AI is also a big challenge for Amazon’s customers: large models turn out to be expensive, their practical use is complicated, and most customers do not have experienced AI experts. Andy Jassy, Amazon’s CEO: “If you think about 90% plus of the global IT spend being on-premises, where I think that equation is going to flip in 10 years. I think cloud is early. So, if you -- with that lens on, I still think we're very early in generative AI.” Andy Jassy on some challenges of large AI models: “a lot of companies figure out quickly is that using the really large -- the large models and the large sizes ends up often being more expensive than what they anticipated and what they want to spend on that application. And sometimes too much latency in getting the answers as it shovels through the really large models.” “still it's complicated to actually figure out which models you want to work, you want to use and how you actually want to employ them and trying to make sure you have the right results, trying to make sure you get safe results, trying to make sure you end up with a cost structure and a customer experience that you want. And so, it's hard. And customers will like -- there's a certain number of customers who have very deep AI expert practitioners, but most companies don't.”

ama 2 xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx.PNG

Amazon Q1 2024 review

Amazon 3D.png

1-May-2024. Amazon Q1 2024 earnings review My key takeaways: 1) Total revenues increased by 12.5% YoY (above expectations, but only +0.51% beat), but at the same time the company's guidance for Q2 disappointed ... mid-range is only $146.5 billion, which means a 2.46% miss - see Figure 1. The "North America" segment performed slightly better +0.83% beat - see Figure 2. However, the "International" segment was disappointing - 1.57% miss - Figure 3. 2) But the most important segment for investors, AWS (amazon web services), was the strongest! Beating expectations by as much as 3.81% - see Figure 4. YoY growth accelerated to 17.2% (from 13.2% in Q4 2023). Figure 5 shows a comparison of the cloud businesses of Microsoft and Google. About AWS, Andy Jassy, CEO: “We remain very bullish on AWS. We're at $100 billion-plus annualized revenue run rate, yet 85% or more of the global IT spend remains on-premises. And this is before you even calculate GenAI, most of which will be created over the next 10 to 20 years from scratch and on the cloud.” „We're seeing a few trends right now. First, companies have largely completed the lion's share of their cost optimization and turned their attention to newer initiatives (…) Our AWS customers are also quite excited about leveraging GenAI to change the customer experiences and businesses. We see considerable momentum on the AI front” About 3 layers of GenAI: “(…) we continue to add capabilities at all three layers of the GenAI stack. At the bottom layer, which is for developers and companies building models themselves, we see excitement about our offerings. We have the broadest selection of NVIDIA compute instances around, but demand for our custom silicon, training, and inference is quite high, given its favorable price performance benefits relative to available alternatives (…) The middle layer of the stack is for developers and companies who prefer not to build models from scratch, but rather seek to leverage an existing large language model, or LLM, customize it with their own data, and have the easiest and best features available to deploy secure high-quality, low-latency, cost-effective production GenAI apps. This is why we built Amazon Bedrock (…) Bedrock already has tens of thousands of customers, including Adidas, New York Stock Exchange, Pfizer, Ryanair, and Toyota. In the last few months, Bedrock's added Anthropic's Claude 3 models, the best-performing models in the planet right now; Meta's Llama 3 models; Mistral's Various models, Cohere's newest models, and new first-party Amazon Titan models. (…) The top of the stack are the GenAI applications being built. And today, we announced the general availability of Amazon Q, the most capable generative AI-powered assistant for software development and leveraging company's internal data. On the software development side, Q doesn't just generate code, it also tests code, debugs coding conflicts, and transforms code from one form to another. Today, developers can save months using Q to move from older versions of Java to newer, more secure and capable ones.” 3) Margins are up significantly! Gross margin and operating margin are the highest in recent years. AWS margins have also increased to historic levels. See Figure 6. 4) Capex is up significantly! Of course, just like in Tesla, Alphabeth, Microsoft, Meta – it's mainly AI related! CEO: „We expect the combination of AWS' reaccelerating growth and high demand for GenAI to meaningfully increase year-over-year capital expenditures in 2024, which given the way the AWS business model works is a positive sign of the future growth. The more demand AWS has, the more we have to procure new data centers, power and hardware. And as a reminder, we spend most of the capital upfront. But as you've seen over the last several years, we make that up in operating margin and free cash flow down the road as demand steadies out. And we don't spend the capital without very clear signals that we can monetize it this way.” Brian Olsavsky, CFO: “As a reminder, we define these as the combination of capex plus equipment finance leases. In 2023, overall capital investments were $48.4 billion. As I mentioned, we're seeing strong AWS demand in both generative AI and our non-generative AI workloads, with customers signing up for longer deals, making bigger commitments. (…) We anticipate our overall capital expenditures to meaningfully increase year over year in 2024, primarily driven by higher infrastructure capex to support growth in AWS, including generative AI.”

Amazon 1.PNG
Amazon 2.PNG
Amazon 3.PNG
Amazon 4.PNG
Amazon 5.PNG
Amazon 6.PNG

Apple Q2 2023 review

Apple Q2 2023 1111.jpeg

4-Aug-2023. Apple Q2 2023 results. As expected, it's a bit of a boring quarter for Apple's earnings. However, there are 3 things to note: 1) Constantly decreasing revenue growth. YoY revenue decreased by 1.4% (with 4 percentage points of FX headwind), the forecast for Q3 is a similar decline in YoY (-1.4%), but FX will subtract only 2 percentage points - i.e. revenue decline accelerates on a constant currency basis. 2) But in return, the profitability of the business is growing and the gross margin in Q2 was the highest in history 44.5% Luca Maestri, CFO: “(…) the 44.5% for the June quarter is an all-time record for us in June. We were up 20 basis points sequentially. It was driven by cost savings and a mix shift towards Services, which obviously helps company gross margins, partially offset by the seasonal loss of leverage. We have a commodity environment that is favorable to us. Our product mix is quite strong at this point. (…) we expect a similar level of gross margins for the same reasons, frankly, for the September quarter.” 3) In order to somehow justify the company's high valuation, "everyone is focused" on current and future growth drivers ... such as: - increase in sales in Emerging Markets, - affordability programs - various forms of crediting/sales promotion, - growth of Services, - AI, very important, but there will be no super breakthrough here, - new products, such as Vision Pro Timothy Cook: “There's enormous excitement around the Vision Pro. We're excited internally. Everybody that's been through the demos are blown away, whether you're talking about press or analysts or developers. (…) I'm using the product daily”. All in all, it is difficult to justify today's valuation of Apple from the financial point of view and the company's (short/medium-term) growth potential. The valuation premium simply depends on other factors…

Apple Q2 2023 2222.jpeg
Apple Q2 2023 3333.jpeg
Apple Q2 2023 4444.jpeg

Apple is down 8.96%

Apple 8 Aug 01.jpeg

8-Aug-2023. Apple is down 8.96% from the recent high, and since it is the largest company, it necessarily has a large impact on the entire market. Weaker financial results for Q2 2023 took their toll.. However, after previous quarterly results, Apple usually outperformed the S&P500 in style: Q1 2023: +4.69% APPL next day +1.85% S&P500 next day Q4 2022: +2.44% APPL next day -1.04% S&P500 next day Q3 2022: +7.56% APPL next day +2.46% S&P500 next day Q2 2022: +3.28% APPL next day +1.42% S&P500 next day Q1 2022: -3.66% APPL next day -3.63% S&P500 next day .. but not today: current quarter Q2 2023: -4.80% APPL next day -0.53% S&P500 next day

Apple 8 Aug 02.jpeg
Apple 8 Aug 03.jpeg

 two bad days -6.4%

Apple 8 SEP 01.jpeg

8-Sep-2023. Apple's share price had two bad days in a row (-6.4% and the S&P500 only -1.0%). And one of the famous sayings is “As Apple goes … goes the market”. The iPhone ban in China is the main reason to blame. But let's also remember about the weak Q2 results. Revenues from China (Greater China Revenue Segment) constitute 19.3% of total revenues. Moreover, this segment's YoY growth is 7.9% in Q2 2023, while total revenues contracted by 1.4% in Q2 YoY (chart). Attached are some charts.

Apple 8 SEP 02.jpeg
Apple 8 SEP 03.jpeg

Apple Q3 2023 review

Wyniki kopia.jpg

6-Nov-2023. Apple. Q3 2023 (calendar) results review (it was formally Q4 2023 for Apple). My 3 main takeaways: 1) The results were rather poor, generally slightly below expectations, and the most important thing... the company is not growing: this is the 4th quarter in a row of decline in YoY revenues, 2) the guidance for Q4 2023 means 0% YoY revenue growth (supposedly an improvement, but Wall Street expected +5%), let's also remember about high inflation when it is relatively easier to achieve nominal revenue growth 3) However, the market does not care too much: since the results were announced, Apple's share price is only 1.46% down relative to the S&P500. Apple has had periods of revenue decline like this before (see the chart, top panel): 1) In 2016, TTM (12-month trailing) revenues decreased by 8.3%. Then came the recovery on TTM sales +23.9% (mainly due to the increase in iPhone sales) 2) In 2019, TTM revenues decreased by 2.7%. Then came a weak rebound in TTM sales of +6.2% (mainly due to the increase in sales of Services and Wearables+) 3) Strong growth 2020-22, TTM revenues increased +43.6% (mainly due to growth in iPhone and Services sales) TTM's current revenue decline YoY is 2.8%. For Apple to make another jump in revenues, it will probably need a significant increase in iPhone sales again... Weaker sales in China do not help either, which in Q3 turned out to be as much as USD 2 billion below Wall Street's expectations. ------------------------ Some more color on revenue growth: it’s fair to say that the strong dollar reduced Apple's sales expressed in USD both in Q3 and the entire fiscal year (last 4 quarters). Foreign exchange had a negative impact of over 2 percentage points in September quarter, and some 3 points over the full reporting year. So, on constant-currency basis it was 0+ revenue growth. Similarly, in China, negative FX impact was nearly 6 points in September quarter. Attention should also be paid to shifts between quarters in the sales of new product versions, as well as shifts related to supply chain disruptions. This especially applies to Mac and iPad sales, which moved from Q2 to Q3 in 2022 – so Q3 YoY comparison is a little bit flawed.

Apple Q4 2023 review

Apple.png

5-Feb-2024. Apple December 2023 quarter earnings review. Part 1. Will the latest technological marvel, Vision Pro glasses, save Apple this year? Apple Vision Pro is available in U.S. stores starting Friday, February 2. There is no doubt about customer delight, but sales volume will be important for investors. This product has the potential to drive the company's revenue growth in 2024. Yet, the lack of significant growth or even the risk of a decline in revenues is the company's main challenge and the main risk for investors that at some point the share price may react negatively. My key takeaways form recent earnings release: 1) Apple's total sales in Q4 2023 grew only 2.1% year-over-year. But in Q4 2022, due to disruptions in supply chains, iPhone sales were approximately $5 billion lower, and this demand was only met in Q1 2023. In other words, $5 billion in sales moved from Q4 2022 to Q1 2023. If we take this effect into account in the comparison of Q4 2022 and Q4 2023, instead of a 2.1% increase we would get a 2.1% decrease in sales. Since nothing in nature is lost, we will formally see this effect in the decline in sales in the first quarter of 2024. And now the analysts' consensus forecast of Apple's revenues in the calendar Q1 2024 is USD 92.5 billion, which means a year-on-year decline of 2.5% - see Figure 1. Figure 2 shows the dollar contributions to the annual change in revenues – by business segments. iPhone added USD 3.9 billion, but if we added USD 5 billion in sales to Q4 2022 - the contribution would be negative. 2) Apple is making up for the lack of sales growth with higher gross profit margin, which has increased from levels of around 38% in 2020 to the current 45.9%. Apple forecasts its further growth in calendar Q1 2024 to the range of 46-47% - see Figure 3. 3) Weak sales in China are a concern (Figure 4). Well-known Apple analyst from TF International Securities, Ming-Chi Kuo recently stated that the new paradigm in phone design includes the use of artificial intelligence and foldable phones, and the main reason for the decline in Apple sales on the Chinese market is the growing interest in foldable phones (which Huawei benefits from). According to Ming-Chi Kuo, shipments of iPhone 15 series and new iPhone 16 series will decline by 10-15% y/y in the first and second half of 2024, respectively.

Apple figure 1.PNG
Apple figure 3.PNG
Apple 2.png
Apple figure 2.PNG
Apple figure 4.PNG

5-Feb-2024. Apple earnings review. Part 2. Continuation of part one: In turn, at the beginning of January 2024, Barclays analysts lowered their recommendations for Apple to "underweight" with a target price of $160. Analysts expect weaker iPhone sales (both in terms of volume and sales mix), and no rebound in Mac, iPad and Wearables. Weaker sales in China in particular will weigh on results. In the case of Mac and iPad, sales may fall to pre-pandemic levels: "These two products combined were basically showing no growth pre-Covid, but are still running 20-30% above those levels despite the rest of the industry correcting." See Figure 5 and 6. Additionally, Barclays analysts expect some deceleration in Services, with regulatory risk ramping. “We model ~10% and ~8%growth in Services in FY24 and FY25, well below prior growth estimate of ~20%. In 2024, we should get an initial determination on the Google TAC, and some app store investigations could intensify.” See Figure 7. So what can have a positive impact on Apple in 2024? Apple Vision Pro will certainly be sold, not only to retail but also commercial customers. Luca Maestri, CFO Apple during the results conference: “Leading organizations across many industries such as Walmart, Nike, Vanguard, Stryker, Bloomberg, and SAP have started leveraging and investing in Apple Vision Pro as their new platform to bring innovative spatial computing experiences to their customers and employees. From everyday productivity to collaborative product design to immersive training, we cannot wait to see the amazing things our enterprise customers will create in the months and years to come.” In the field of artificial intelligence, Apple - unlike other companies - does not provide greater details, but announced that in 2024 it will show what steps the company has taken in this regard. Market expectations in this area are very high. Tim Cook, CEO of Apple during the earnings conference: “As we look ahead, we will continue to invest in these and other technologies that will shape the future. That includes artificial intelligence where we continue to spend a tremendous amount of time and effort, and we're excited to share the details of our ongoing work in that space later this year.” Tim Cook on the high price of Apple Vision Pro: “(…) from a price point of view, there's an incredible amount of technology that's packed into the product. There's 5,000 patents in the product and it's, of course, built on many innovations that Apple has spent multiple years on, from silicon to displays and significant AI and machine learning. All the hand tracking, the room mapping, all of this stuff is driven by AI. And so, we're incredibly excited about it. I can't wait to be in the store for tomorrow and see the reaction myself.”

Apple figure 5.PNG
Apple figure 6.PNG
Apple figure 7.PNG

Apple Q1 2024 review

apple 3D.png

4-May-2024. Apple March Quarter 2024 Earnings Review My key takeaways: 1) First, it's going to be flat nominal growth at best. And this in an environment of high inflation. Investors should probably get used to this. The company is too large for any new and innovative products to significantly accelerate the growth of total revenues (in the short term). 2) If investors "accept flat growth" - then practically all other important factors related to the company are fine and solid - starting from a strong brand, customer satisfaction, market position, margins, further products, Vision Pro, expectations regarding AI applications, growing dividend and increasingly larger share buybacks, etc. Tim Cook, CEO: „In services, we set an all-time revenue record, up 14% over the past year. Keep in mind, as we described on the last call, in the March quarter a year-ago, we were able to replenish iPhone channel inventory and fulfill significant pent-up demand from the December quarter COVID-related supply disruptions on the iPhone 14 Pro and 14 Pro Max. We estimate this one-time impact added close to $5 billion to the March quarter revenue last year. If we remove this from last year's results, our March quarter total company revenue this year would have grown.” And about GenAI: „We continue to feel very bullish about our opportunity in Generative AI. We are making significant investments, and we're looking forward to sharing some very exciting things with our customers soon. We believe in the transformative power and promise of AI, and we believe we have advantages that will differentiate us in this new era, including Apple's unique combination of seamless hardware, software and services integration, groundbreaking Apple's silicon, with our industry-leading neural engines and our unwavering focus on privacy” And the remaining takeaways: 3) Revenues decreased YoY by 4.8% and this is the 5th quarter of negative annual growth over the last 6 quarters - see Figure 1. A year ago, approximately $5 billion in iPhone sales moved from Q4 2022 to Q1 2023 - if we adjusted the results for this, then Q4 would be negative (-2.1%) and the current quarter positive (+1.02%). It is also worth noting the significant decline in Wall Street expectations regarding Apple's revenue growth - see Figure 2 (and comparison of the consensus change from February to April 2024). 4) Year over year, Apple recorded revenue growth only on Mac sales (+$0.28 billion YoY) and Services (+$2.96 billion) - see Figure 3. The remaining product categories were negative year over year - see Figure 4. 5) To counterbalance and somehow satisfy shareholders... Apple increased its share buyback program to $110 billion and also increased its dividend by 4% to $0.25 per share. 6) Revenues may not be growing as investors would like, but in return the gross profit margin is constantly growing - and in Q1 it reached as much as 46.6% - see Figure 5. This is due to growing margins in services (and falling margins on products) - see Figure 6. Luca Maestri, CFO: „Company gross margin was 46.6%, up 70 basis points sequentially, driven by cost savings and favorable mix to services, partially offset by leverage. Products gross margin was 36.6%, down 280 basis points sequentially, primarily driven by seasonal loss of leverage and mix, partially offset by favorable costs. Services gross margin was 74.6%, up 180 basis points from last quarter due to a more favorable mix.” 7) Investors pay a lot of attention to the Chinese market (there were a lot of questions about China at the results conference). Sales in the Chinese market decreased YoY by 8.1% (-$1.44 billion). This is a smaller decline than in the previous quarter, when it amounted to -12.9%. See Figure 7. However, the company remains optimistic about the Chinese market… Tim Cook: „(…) if you look at our results in Q2 for Greater China, we were down 8%. That’s an acceleration from the previous quarter in Q1. And the primary driver of the acceleration was iPhone. And if you then look at iPhone within Mainland China, we grew on a reported basis. That’s before any kind of normalization for the supply disruption that we mentioned earlier. And if you look at the top-selling smartphones, the Top 2 in Urban China are iPhones. And while I was there, it was a great visit and we opened a new store in Shanghai and the reception was very warm and highly energetic (…). And so I maintain a great view of China in the long-term. I don’t know how each and every quarter goes and each and every week. But over the long haul, I have a very positive viewpoint.”

Apple Q1 1.PNG
Apple Q1 2.PNG
Apple Q1 3.PNG
Apple Q1 5.PNG
Apple Q1 7.PNG
Apple Q1 4.png
Apple Q1 6.PNG

Meta Q2 2023 review

Meta Q2 2023 1.jpeg

28-Jul-2023. Meta Platforms: also delivered strong results for Q2 2023. Not only from the macro side we see that the economy is strong, but also from the side of the results of companies such as Meta or Alphabet (in general a strong advertising market drives revenue growth). In the case of Meta, the market expected YoY revenue growth in Q2 2023 of +7.8%, and received +11.0%. In addition, in Q3 revenue growth will amount to +20.0% (the middle of the company's forecast range), while the market expected only +12.6%. Susan Li, CFO on Q2 revenue acceleration: “Within ad revenue (JJ: ad rev constitutes just 98,4% of total rev), the online commerce vertical was the largest contributor to year-over-year growth, followed by entertainment & media and CPG (…). On a user geography basis, ad revenue growth was strongest in Rest of World at 16%, followed by Europe, North America and Asia-Pacific at 14%, 11% and 10%, respectively (…). In terms of the Q2 revenue acceleration, I'd highlight there are a few factors driving that. The first is, frankly, we're lapping a weaker demand period, including the first full quarter of the war in Ukraine and the suspension of our services in Russia. Second, we saw increased supply and improvements to ad performance, including improved Reels monetization as we continue to work down the Reels revenue headwind. And third, there were lower FX headwinds for us this quarter. So those were all three things that helped drive the revenue acceleration in Q2 (…).” And Susan’s comments on Q3 and Q4 revenue acceleration: “Turning now to the revenue outlook. We expect third quarter 2023 total revenue to be in the range of $32-34.5 billion. Our guidance assumes a foreign currency tailwind of approximately 3% to year-over-year total revenue growth in the third quarter, based on current exchange rates (…). So on the further acceleration that we've guided to in Q3, first of all, I'd just point out that Q3'22 revenue declined 4.5% year-over-year so we're really lapping a much weaker demand period a year ago, and we've certainly seen demand this year stabilize and so it's really a much easier compare. We also are expecting that currency is going to flip to a 3-point tailwind from a 1-point headwind last quarter (…). In terms of what this means for Q4, we're not sharing a Q4 revenue outlook yet. There are obviously some tailwinds to year-over-year growth in Q4. Again, the same point about a weaker compare applies. And at current rates, FX would be a larger tailwind in Q4 than we're expecting it to be in Q3. But we've had sizable fluctuations in advertiser demand over the last year. It's been a pretty volatile period. So while we're seeing strong advertiser demand now and that's certainly informing our outlook, it's harder to predict as we look further forward (…).”

Meta Q2 2023 2.jpeg
Meta Q2 2023 3.jpeg
Meta Q2 2023 4444.jpeg

29-Jul-2023. Meta Platforms, a little more about financial results and a new business line generating huge losses. The Reality Labs business segment generates approximately $4 billion in operating loss per quarter. This is a lot, because it’s about 1/3 of the operating profit from the profitable part of the company's business (Family of Apps). Operating loss in 2022 within Reality Labs amounted to USD 13.7 billion, in 2023 it will be higher, and in 2024 according to Susan Li, CFO: "for Rality Labs, we expect operating losses to increase meaningfully year-over-year due to our ongoing product development efforts in AR/VR (JJ: Augmented Reality / Virtual Reality) and our investments to further scale our ecosystem.” So next year, the cumulative losses from Reality Labs will approach $50 billion. What does the money at Reality Labs mainly go to? The Meta doesn't provide details, but it's generally about the Quest 3 headset, VR, AR, investment in metaverse social platforms and neural interfaces. Such losses worry investors ... Goldman Sachs analyst during the earnings conference: „(…) The RL losses just continue to build. And I think we continue to struggle a little bit of what drivers of those losses are and how should we think about some of the components driving the losses versus elements of earning a return on those losses over the medium to long term”. Bank of America Merrill Lynch analyst: “I guess I want to follow up on Reality Labs, passing $40 billion in losses and increasing annually next year. Just think about -- maybe help us understand how the ROI on the business, how you're thinking about that investment, either on a stand-alone basis or as a complement to the Family of Apps, if you're thinking about it from an investor perspective.“ In response, Mark Zuckerberg: “(…) I know from an investor standpoint, most people aren't investing on quite as long of a time horizon as we are here, so I kind of get that, a lot of investors might want to see us spending less here in the near term. My view is that we are leading in these areas. I believe that they're going to be big over time. I think we've shown that we can deliver good business results in the near term while investing ambitiously in the long term. So I'm planning on continuing to do that, and I do continue to believe that over time, we will be happy that we did that.” “(…) This is a very long-term bet. At a deep level, I understand the discomfort that a lot of investors have with it because it's just outside of the model of, I think, even most long-term investors, how you would think about this. And look, I mean, I can't guarantee you that I'm going to be right about this bet. I do think that this is the direction that the world is going in. There are 1 billion or 2 billion people who have glasses today. I think in the future, they're all going to be smart glasses.”

Meta Q2 2023 5555.jpeg

Meta Q3 2023 review

meta Q3 1.PNG

26-Oct-2023. Meta. Q3 2023 earnings review. Immediately after the publication of the results, the Meta price increased by appr. 4% (in after-hours trading), but a few hours later it dropped to some -3% from the close of cash market. Q3 results beat expectations: 1) Total revenues amounted to $34.15 billion (+1.8% sales surprise), which means +23.2% YoY (expected +20.9%), Chart 1, 2) Advertising revenues amounted to $33.64 billion (+2.1% sales surprise), which means +23.5% YoY (expected +20.9%), Chart 2, 3) Diluted EPS $4.39 (+20.9% EPS surprise), which means +168% YoY (expected +121%). The remaining revenue segments are immaterial. Meta also reports Other Revenue (only 0.86% of total revenues), and Reality Labs revenues (only 0.62% of total revenues). Meta also reports the Family of Apps segment, which is the sum of Advertising and Other Revenue. Important points from CFO's outlook commentary: 1) Expected total revenues in Q4 2023 are $36.5-40 billion (this would mean YoY +13.5-24.4%), 2) Repeated statement from Q2 that Reality Labs' operating loss will increase YoY in 2023, 3) Repeated statement from Q2 that Reality Labs' operating loss will increase significantly in 2024: "we expect operating losses to increase meaningfully year-over-year due to our ongoing product development efforts in augmented reality/virtual reality and our investments to further scale our ecosystem", 4) They reduced the CAPEX forecast for 2023 by approximately 3% vs. the previous forecast from Q2 (to the level of $27-29 billion), 5) They provided a CAPEX forecast for 2024: $30-35 billion (the CAPEX increase is: " (...) driven by investments in servers, including both non-artificial intelligence (AI) and AI hardware, and data centers as we ramp up construction on sites with the new data center architecture we announced late last year.” Reality Laps brings huge losses. The cumulative operating loss since Q1 2021 is $35.4 billion and will exceed $50 billion next year. Fortunately, the growth of the business (the profitable part) reduces the share of the loss in the operating profit of the profitable part of the business - see chart 3.

meta Q3 2.PNG
meta Q3 3.PNG

Meta Q1 2024 review

Meta Q12024 3D v2.png

25-Apr-2024. Meta Q1 2024 Earnings Review Meta has beaten analysts' expectations and the stock is down 15%. Go figure! Meta reported Q1 2024 Revenue of $36.46 billion (vs. expected $36.15 billion) with a +0.8% beat - see Figure 1. However, Q2 2024 revenue guidance missed Wall Street expectations by only 1.3% and this is apparently the main reason for the price drop - see Figure 2. Importantly, Meta provides a revenue range as guidance for the next quarter. An additional reason cited in the media is higher CAPEX. Wall Street expected CAPEX in 2024 at $34.89 billion. CFO Outlook Commentary: “We anticipate our full-year 2024 capital expenditures will be in the range of $35-40 billion, increased from our prior range of $30-37 billion as we continue to accelerate our infrastructure investments to support our artificial intelligence (AI) roadmap. While we are not providing guidance for years beyond 2024, we expect capital expenditures will continue to increase next year as we invest aggressively to support our ambitious AI research and product development efforts.” All in all, my gut feeling is that we are just in the middle of a mean-reverting stock market correction – so Meta has just joined the harder falling stocks because it had previously grown significantly. Missed guidance or higher CAPEX was just a trigger and/or an excuse.

Meta Q12024 1.PNG
Meta Q12024 2.PNG

Microsoft Q2 2023 review

Microsoft Q2 2023 1111.jpeg

26-Jul-2023. Microsoft showed solid Q2 results beating expectations on virtually every major data item. However, this is not enough considering the price, which is about 3-4% down (in after-hours market). Revenue growth is declining slightly, on a 12-month basis (TTM) the increase is +6.9% YoY (chart), and comparing quarter to quarter YoY +8.3% (chart). Azur which is the main growth engine (cloud platform) is growing 27% YoY (but down from 31% excluding currency fluctuations) and according to the company guidelines it will be between 25%-26% in the next quarter (chart). As part of Azur .. AI services is currently "only" 1 percentage point of the growth. AI .. the future growth engine is just future when it comes to concrete revenues, CFO Amy Hood: “Even with strong demand and a leadership position, growth from our AI services will be gradual as Azure AI scales and our copilots reach general availability dates. So, for FY24, the impact will be weighted towards H2.” However AI is the future, as CEO Satya Nadella said: "Every customer I speak with is asking not only how, but how fast, they can apply next generation AI". Interestingly, the "Azure OpenAI" service acquires almost 100 customers a day, Satya Nadella: "We have great momentum across Azure OpenAI Service. More than 11,000 organizations across industries, including Ikea, Volvo Group, Zurich Insurance (…) use the service. That’s nearly 100 new customers added every day this quarter.”

Microsoft Q2 2023 2222.jpeg
Microsoft Q2 2023 3333.jpeg
Microsoft Q2 2023 4444.jpeg

Microsoft Q3 2023 review

ms 1.PNG

25-Oct-2023. Microsoft. Q1 2024 Earnings (short) review (it's Q3 2023 on calendar basis). Microsoft beat expectations at every revenue level. Total revenues amounted to $56.52 billion (+3.63% sales surprise, Chart 1). Microsoft divides revenues into 3 segments: 1) Productivity and Business Processes (e.g. Office and LinkedIn are here) $18.59 billion (+1.64% sales surprise), Chart 2, 2) Intelligent Cloud (e.g. Azur, Server Products) $24.26 billion (+2.75% sales surprise), Chart 3, 3) More Personal Computing (e.g. Windows, Gaming, Search) $13.67 billion (+6.05% sales surprise), Chart 4. Of course, the most important segment for the markets today is the Intelligent Cloud, which can be compared to Alphabet’s Google Cloud. Comparison: Microsoft: Intelligent Cloud Revenue $24.3 billion, beat +2.75%, YoY +19.4% and YoY +$3.92 billion, Alphabet: Google Cloud Revenue $8.4 billion, miss -2.21%, YoY +22.5% and YoY +$1.54 billion. Microsoft also beat expectations at the EPS level, which amounted to $2.99 per diluted share (+12.83% EPS surprise).

ms 2.PNG
ms 3.PNG
ms 4.PNG

Microsoft Q1 2024 review

Microsoft Q12024 3D.png

30-Apr-2024. Microsoft Q3 2024 Earnings review (it's Q1 2024 on calendar basis) My key takeaways: Microsoft beat expectations at every revenue segment. So it’s solid growth and one can assume that could continue in following quarters. Azur (Microsoft’s cloud infrastructure platform) is key, and it’s doing extremely well. CAPEX is booming and it’s AI related. Re 1) Total revenues amounted to $61.86 billion (+1.59% sales beat, Figure 1). Microsoft divides revenues into 3 segments: First, Productivity and Business Processes (e.g. Office and LinkedIn are here) $19.57 billion (slight beat, but practically in line with expectations), Figure 2, Second, Intelligent Cloud (e.g. Azur, Server Products) $26.71 billion (+1.75% sales beat), Figure 3, Third, More Personal Computing (e.g. Windows, Gaming, Search) $15.58 billion (+3.38% sales beat), Figure 4. Amy Hood, CFO, on "More Personal Computing" segment: “Revenue was $15.6 billion, increasing 17%, with 15 points of net impact from the Activision acquisition. Results were above expectations driven by better-than-expected performance in Gaming and Windows OEM”. Re 2) Intelligent Cloud segment can be compared to Alphabet’s Google Cloud and Amazon’s AWS – see Figure 5. Recently generative AI has kicked off the next wave of cloud expansion. About 70% of Intelligent Could Division's revenues come from Azur, Microsoft's cloud infrastructure platform. Azur is doing extremely well and is growing 31% YoY, which is very positive for investors - as many as 7 percentage points of this growth are due to AI Services: Satya Nadella, CEO: “Our AI innovation continues to build on our strategic partnership with OpenAI. More than 65% of the Fortune 500 now use Azure OpenAI Service”. “Azure has become a port of call for pretty much anybody who is doing any AI project.” Amy Hood: “Azure and other cloud services revenue grew 31%, ahead of expectations, while our AI services contributed 7 points of growth as expected” And on the Azur’s outlook: “In Azure, we expect Q4 revenue growth to be 30% to 31% in constant currency, or similar to our stronger-than-expected Q3 result. Growth will be driven by our Azure consumption business and continued contribution from AI with some impact from the AI capacity availability” “ (…) we do have demand that exceeds our supply by a bit. It is fair to say that that could have been an impact on the number for the quarter and does impact a little bit the number in Q4.” Re 3) Capex is accelerating. But the management feels good about it. Amy Hood: “We expect capital expenditures to increase materially on a sequential basis driven by cloud and AI infrastructure investments. As a reminder, there can be normal quarterly spend variability in the timing of our cloud infrastructure buildout and the timing of finance leases. We continue to bring capacity online as we scale our AI investments with growing demand. Currently, near-term AI demand is a bit higher than our available capacity.“ “To scale to meet the growing demand signal for our cloud and AI products, we expect FY25 capital expenditures to be higher than FY24. These expenditures over the course of the next year are dependent on demand signals and adoption of our services, so we will manage that signal thru the year.”

Microsoft Q12024 1.PNG
Microsoft Q12024 2.PNG
Microsoft Q12024 3.PNG
Microsoft Q12024 4.PNG
Microsoft Q12024 5.PNG

Novo Nordisk Q3 2023 review

Novo1.PNG

2-Nov-2023. Novo Nordisk. The largest EU company by market-cap. Short Q3 earnings review. Novo Nordisk shares have already increased by 48.4% this year - which is as much as the largest US companies - see chart 1. Today, Novo Nordisk published its results for Q3 2023, slightly beating Wall Street estimates. However, two weeks ago (13-Oct), Novo Nordisk raised its earnings forecast for 2023 (e.g. raised its revenue forecast to 32-38% growth in 2023 from the previous forecast of 27-33%), so analysts had an easier time forecasting results. Revenues in Q3 increased 28.9% YoY in DKK to DKK 58.7 trillion - see chart 2. Two factors are responsible for the increase in sales: 1) the world-famous anti-obesity drug Wegovy: +734% YoY (+ DKK 8.5 trillion) – see chart 3 2) and the diabetes drug Ozempic, which accounts for as much as 78% of sales of the GLP1 (glucagon-like peptide-1 drugs) segment - see chart 4. The demand for Wegovy is so high that the company's main challenge now is to keep up with production! Well, sort of luxury problem…

Sales kopia.jpg
Novo2.PNG
Novo3.PNG
Novo5.PNG

3-Nov-2023. Novo Nordisk. Q3 earnings review. Part 2. The Novo Nordisk share price has increased by 196.2% since December 31, 2020. At the same time: 1) S&P500 is +14.95% 2) NYSE ARCA Pharmaceutical Index +26.41%. See chart 1 3) Nvidia +233.9% 4) Apple +35.4% But, for example, the rate of returns from 31-Dec-2019 look like this: 1) Novo Nordisk +263.0% 2) S&P500 is +33.6% 3) NYSE ARCA Pharmaceutical Index +33.3% 4) Nvidia +642.1% 5) Apple +146.9% Chart 2 shows the relative (vs. NYSE ARCA Pharmaceutical Index) behavior of the Novo Nordisk share price after the publication of results for the last 4 quarters.

Novo4.PNG

Novo Nordisk's Wegovy Q4

20-Feb-2024. Novo Nordisk's Wegovy blockbuster. My key takeaways form recent earnings and market developments (part 1): 1) This is a comfortable situation for the company when the demand for anti-obesity drugs is growing rapidly and the main challenge is to increase production capacity. The main drug in this area is Wegovy, approved by the FDA in 2021. Wegovy's full-year 2023 sales increased by 407% (from DKK 6.2 billion in 2022 to DKK 31.3 billion in 2023) - see Figure 1, which shows Wegovy's quarterly revenues and Wall Street consensus estimate for 2024-2025, 2) Competition from Eli Lilly in the obesity drug space is only helping to excite investors about the prospects of the anti-obesity drug market. The share prices of Novo Nordisk and Eli Lilly are moving together, significantly outperforming the S&P500 as well as the NYSE ARCA Pharmaceutical Index - see Figure 2 3) Eli Lilly's Zepbound got the FDA's approval on November 8, 2023, and was available for sale from December 5 - and in December 2023 alone, sales amounted to $175 million. When publishing its results on February 6, 2024, the company boasted about the success of Zepbound - Figure 3. 4) In the case of Zepbound, Wall Street forecasts strong sales growth in the coming quarters – see Figure 4.

Novo Nordisk PNG.png
FEB 20 Figure1.PNG
FEB 20 Figure2.PNG
FEB 20 Figure3.png
FEB 20 Figure4.PNG

Novo Nordisk Q4 2023 review

NovoPart2_grafika.png

27-Feb-2024. Novo Nordisk's Wegovy blockbuster (part 2) Novo Nordisk's revenues in Q4 2023 increased year-on-year by 37% (+DKK 17.8 billion) to DKK 65.863 billion. Figure 1. The largest share of sales is GLP-1, see Figure 2. The quarterly change in revenue was DKK +7.132 billion. The largest contribution is GLP-1 +DKK 7.126 billion (Figure 3). The two largest contributors to the annual change in revenues are Wegovy (+DKK 7.2 billion) and GLP-1 (+DKK 13.4 billion). These two items give an annual increase of +DKK 20.6 billion - which is more than the total increase in revenues (all other items decreased year-on-year). Wegovy and Saxenda medicines constitute the "Total Obecity Care" segment. Figure 4 shows the annual contribution to the revenue change. Key takeaway: the drastic increase in demand applies not only to drugs dedicated to obesity but also to drugs for diabetes (with the same active substance). Both in the case of Novo Nordisk (in the case of Ozempic and Wegovy, the active substance is semaglutide – Figure 5) and in the case of Eli Lilly (Mounjaro and Zepbound - the active substance is tirzepatide - Figure 6).

NovoPart2_1.PNG
NovoPart2_2.PNG
NovoPart2_3.PNG
NovoPart2_4.PNG
NovoPart2_5.PNG
NovoPart2_6.PNG

Novo Nordisk CMD'24 review

NN 3D pic.png

8-Mar-2024. + 9% up only today! Novo Nordisk's stock is up 9% today and so far... 31% up this year. Today there was the Capital Market Day for investors, during which Novo Nordisk presented 3 main takeaways regarding anti-obesity drugs: 1) Wegovy® has unlocked the obesity care market yet a large unmet need remains. NN (Novo Nordisk) achieved sales of anti-obesity drugs in the amount of DKK 42 billion in 2023 (Figure 1). But only 1 million patients out of 813 million take obesity medications today (Figure 2). And in 2030, this number will increase to 1,246 million people (adults) - Figure 3. 2) SELECT trial is a key differentiator with semaglutide 2.4 mg as the first and only AOM treatment with a proven CV benefit. AOM stands for anti-obesity medications, CV is cardiovascular. Semaglutide treats not only obesity but also other obesity-related comorbidities. CVs are particularly important, as they may allow for more refinancing of treatment by payers. The SELECT population represents ca. 10% of the total obesity population. See Figure 4 and 5. 3) Pipeline and supply capacity support continued NN leadership in obesity. NN presented its entire portfolio of anti-obesity drugs in development (Figure 6), but the most important for investors are the Phase 1 results for Amycretin - a once daily oral co-agonist - which causes weight loss by 13.1% after 12 weeks (Figure 7). Amycretin uses the same GLP-1 hormone as other weight-loss drugs, such as NN's Wegovy or Eli Lilly's Zepbound. The key here is the fact that it also stimulates the amylin hormone, which regulates hunger. 13% weight loss is twice as good as in the case of subcutaneous Wegovy!

NN 1.png
NN 2.png
NN 3.png
NN 4.png
NN 5.png
NN 6.png
NN 7.png

Novo Nordisk Q1 2024 review

Novo Q1 3D.png

2-May-2024. Novo Nordisk Q1 2024 Earnings Review My key takeaways: 1) Total revenue beat +2.65%, Operating profit beat +10.4%, Net profit beat +10.0%, EPS diluted beat +8.75% 2) Revenues increased YoY by 22.5% - additionally, in the last two months analysts have significantly increased their revenue growth forecasts in the following years - see Figure 1 3) However, quarter-on-quarter revenues decreased by 0.78% - see Figure 2 (rev split by segments). Total GLP-1 revenues decreased the most quarter by quarter by DKK -2.78 billion - see Figure 3. Wegovy's sales have not been growing for 3 quarters either. The company has not been able to meet demand for practically a year: “Demand for Wegovy® exceeds supply, and to safeguard continuity of care, supply of the lower Wegovy® dose strengths in the US has been reduced since May 2023. Novo Nordisk started gradually increasing the supply of the lower strength doses in January 2024.” 4) Novo Nordisk is going to expand its production capacity to meet up the demand for weight-loss drugs. The company announced an agreement to acquire three fill-finish sites from Novo Holdings A/S, following Novo Holdings A/S's acquisition of Catalent. This acquisition is expected to be a significant boost to the company's manufacturing capabilities. 5) The company also slightly raised its financial outlook for the entire year 2024. Currently, the company expects sales to increase by 19-27% (it was 18-26% - outlook from January 31 this year). The increase in operating profit is expected to be between 22-30% throughout 2024 (was 21-29%) 6) But year on year, the company achieved a significant increase in revenues of key drugs: Ozempic +41.6% (DKK +8.17 bln) Wegovy +105.5% (DKK +4.81 bln) Ozempic + Wegovy YoY = DKK +12.98 bln Total GLP-1 (here is Ozempic) +30.5% (DKK +8.17 bln) Total Obesity (here is Wegovy) +40.7% (DKK +3.19 bln) Total Sales +22.5% (DKK +11.98 bln) Figure 4 details the YoY change in DKK billion.

Novo Q1 1.PNG
Novo Q1 2 v2.PNG
Novo Q1 3.PNG
Novo Q1 4.PNG

Novo Nordisk consensus

Novo 9 May 07 3D.png

9-May-2024. Novo Nordisk and Elli Lilly benefit from the sale of weight-loss drugs. Investors also benefit, only this year the prices of these producers increased 2-3 times more than S&P500 or NYSE ARCA Pharmaceutical Index - see Figure 1. The Novo Nordisk share price reacted a bit negatively to the earnings announced on May 2 this year (among others there was a miss on the Wegovy sales). It is therefore worth checking how Wall Street's expectations regarding revenue growth have changed after the publication of financial results (when analysts had time to "digest" all the new data). Figure 2 shows the change in the consensus for total revenues (we compare the consensus after the announced results for Q4 2023 (dated 19-Feb-2024), the consensus before the announcement of Q1 2024 results (19-Apr-2024) and the consensus after the announced results for Q1 2024 (8-May-2024). Figure 3 shows this data in a zoom-in version. All-in-all analysts increased their revenue growth expectations for the subsequent 4 quarters by 1.5% (highlighted in green, at the bottom of the chart). Figure 4 shows the consensus change for Wegovy: +5.4% higher revenues over the subsequent 4 quarters. That's quite positive! Figure 5 shows the change in the consensus for Ozempic: only +0.1% - but sales in Q1 beat expectations by as much as 4.24%. All in all, according to Wall Street, Novo Nordisk's revenues will grow faster than analysts expected before the results were published. The negative reaction of the stock price seems to be short-lived. Bonus Charts: Figure 6 and 7 show sales growth of Eli Lilly's competitive drugs (Zepbound and Mounjaro), including published results for Q1 2024.

Novo 9 May 01.PNG
Novo 9 May 02.PNG
Novo 9 May 03.PNG
Novo 9 May 04.PNG
Novo 9 May 05.PNG
Novo 9 May 06.PNG
Novo 9 May 07.PNG

Nvidia Q2 2023 preview

Nvidia Q2 23 preview 001.jpeg

22-Aug-2023. Nvidia reports results tomorrow after the market close. Since the October 2022 low, Nvidia's price has already increased by over 320%. So, isn't the bar set too high for another positive surprise? Previously, after the publication of the Q1 2023 results, Nvidia's share price increased by 24% the next day (see chart). Relative to the S&P500, after 17 trading days relative performance was +37% (second chart). After the publication of the Q4 2022 results, the next day Nvidia's share price increased by 14%. And how are the other 6 largest technology companies doing - after the publication of the Q2 2023 results? The best Alphabet +9.6% against the S&P500. Worst Tesla -16% vs S&P500 (see next chart).

Nvidia Q2 23 preview 002.jpeg
Nvidia Q2 23 preview 003.jpeg
Nvidia Q2 23 preview 004.jpeg

Nvidia Q2 2023 review

Nvidia Q2 2023 1.jpeg

24-Aug-2023. Nvidia - Q2 results. Revenue skyrocketed, growing +101% YoY and +88% sequentially QoQ. Nevertheless, 96% of the increase in revenues is accounted for (both YoY and QoQ) by one segment... namely Data Centers. No wonder, it was in this segment that the demand for AI materialized. CFO Commentary: “Data Center revenue was a record, up 171% from a year ago and up 141% sequentially, led by cloud service providers and large consumer internet companies. Strong demand (…) was primarily driven by the development of large language models and generative AI.”

Nvidia Q2 2023 2.jpeg

24-Aug-2023. Nvidia - part 2. The increase in revenues per segment (and their share in total revenues) is clearly visible in the charts below for individual segments, where the Y scale is the same for all charts.

Nvidia Q2 2023 3.jpeg
Nvidia Q2 2023 4.jpeg
Nvidia Q2 2023 5.jpeg

Nvidia +21.8% to ATH

Nvidia 21% 001.jpeg

16-Nov-2023. Nvidia +21.8% in 10 days to ATH Nvidia stock rose for the tenth consecutive session to a new all-time high on 14-Nov. This represents an increase of 21.8% (closing prices, 1-Nov to 14-Nov). Yesterday Nvidia had a first negative session (-1.55%). Nvidia is the top performer from the entire Mag7 club, counting since the publication of Q1 2023 earnings. Nominally, Nvidia has increased by 60.1% since May 24, 2023, and relative to the S&P500 by 50.7%. See Table 1, bottom panel. In second place is Meta with a rate of return since the publication of Q1 2023 results +58.9% nominally, and +47.9% relatively to the S&P500 (see table 1 and chart 1). Chart 2 shows Nvidia’s stock price since 2021. Recently, other companies have also been on a good streak: Microsoft: 9 positive days in a row (27-Oct to 8-Nov +10.8%), Meta: 8 positive days in a row (3-Nov to 14-Nov +8.2%), Amazon: 8 positive days in a row (27-Oct to 7-Nov +19.4%), S&P500: 8 positive days in a row (30-Oct to 8-Nov +6.5%).

Nvidia 21% 002.jpeg
Nvidia 21% 003.jpeg

nvidia Q3 2023 preview 

Nvidia 001.PNG

21-Nov-2023. Nvidia Q3 2023 earnings preview. The Nvidia share price reached its all-time-high yesterday - exactly one day before the publication of Q3 2023 results (earnings are due today after the market close). The most important things to watch: 1) Beat/miss on sales, Nvidia's Q2 revenues grew 101.5% YoY (beating Wall Street expectations by 22.3%). The market expects Q3 revenues of $16.2 billion (which means a YoY increase of 173%). 2) Beat/miss on adjusted EPS, In Q2, adjusted EPS was $2.70 (+430% YoY and beat Wall Street expectations by 30.4%). The market expects $3.37 in Q3 (a year ago it was $0.58). 3) Revenue growth in the Data Center segment, This is key, as this segment houses the company's AI chips division. 4) China, On October 17, Nvidia's stock price fell 7.5% after news that President Biden intends to restrict the sale of AI chips to China. Nvidia has asserted that the impact in the near term may not be significant, however the long-term effects could be more pronounced. 5) Competition from other tech giants E.g. production of their own AI chips. 6) Potential disruptions in the supply chain. The Nvidia share price increased from the publication of the Q1 results (24-May-2023) to 20-Nov-2023 nominally by 61.5%, and relative to the S&P500 by 54.6% (see the chart).

nvidia Q3 2023 earnings

Nvidia Q3 1.jpeg
Nvidia Q3 2.jpeg

23-Nov-2023. Nvidia Q3 earnings. Nvidia reported blowout Q3 2023 results, however the stock is down in after-hours trading (-1,15% at the moment of writing). First take: 1) Revenue $18.2 billion (expected $16.2 billion, +11.8% beat), YoY +205.5% (expected +173%). Figure 1. 2) Adjusted EPS $4.02 (expected $3.37, +19.3% beat). 3) Data Center Segment Revenue $14.51 billion (expected $12.82 billion, +13.2% beat), YoY +279% (expected +234%). 4) Revenue Q4 Guidance $20.0 billion (plus/minus 2%). Figure 2 shows revenue segments and Q4 guidance. This guidance means 230% YoY revenue growth in Q4. 5) On export to China... unfortunately there is no good news here. Export restrictions to China have already come into force and Nvidia expects a significant decline in sales in Q4. The CFO's detailed commentary in this regard is presented in Figure 3.

Nvidia Q3 3.jpeg
Nvidia Q3 4.jpeg
Nvidia Q3 5.jpeg

23-Nov-2023. Nvidia Q3 Earnings, part 2. Growth Engines in Full Throttle. Jen-Hsun Huang, Nvidia's CEO during the earnings conference: “NVIDIA GPUs, CPUs, networking, AI foundry services, and NVIDIA AI enterprise software are all growth engines in full throttle.” And indeed, the growth of Nvidia's business is impressive. The same when it comes to the further growth and prospects of AI. In fact, the entire results conference only confirmed this... except for one aspect... the company admitted that the revenue forecast for Q4 could have been higher if not for China. Colette Kress, CFO: „But with the absence of China, for our outlook for Q4, sure, there could have been some things that we are not supply constrained that we could have sold to China, but we no longer can. So, could our guidance have been a little higher in our Q4? Yes.” And some more color form CFO on export ban: “U.S. government announced a new set of export control regulations for China and other markets, including Vietnam and certain countries in the Middle East. These regulations require licenses for the export of a number of our products, including our Hopper and MPIR 100 and 800 series and several others (…). We expect that our sales to these destinations will decline significantly in the fourth quarter (…) For the highest performance levels, the government requires licenses. For lower performance levels, the government requires a streamlined prior notification process. And for products, even lower performance levels, the government does not require any notice at all. (…) We are working with some customers in China and the Middle East to pursue licenses from the U.S. government. It is too early to know whether these will be granted for any significant amount of revenue.” “The export controls will have a negative effect on our China business, and we do not have good visibility into the magnitude of that impact even over the long term.” “(…) regarding potentially new products that we could provide to our China customers. It's a significant process to both design and develop these new products. As we discussed, we're going to make sure that we are in full discussions with the U.S. government of our intent in these products as well (…). And going forward, whether that's medium term or long term, it's just hard to say both the ideas of what we can produce with the U.S. government and with the interest of our China customers. So, we stay still focused on finding that right balance for our China customers, but it's hard to say at this time.” Attached charts showing quarter on quarter and year on year revenue growth - divided into segments by market platform. Apart from the obvious growth of Data Center, Gaming and Professional Visualization are also performing well both sequentially and year on year.

market reaction to nvidia Q3 2023 

wy1.PNG

23-Nov-2023. Nvidia underperforms S&P500. Nvidia closes the first day of trading after the publication of Q3 2023 results with a slight loss: nominally -2.46% and relatively to the S&P500 -2.86%. While the share price reacted spectacularly after the results for Q4 2022 and Q1 2023, the last two quarters were not so good (the price oscillates relatively around the S&P500, Chart 1). It seems that the great financial results were already reflected in the share prices. However, since the publication of the Q4 2022 results, the rate of return is still impressive: nominally +134.7% and +120.6% relative to the S&P500 - see chart 2. Table 1 summarizes the results of Mag7 and Novo Nordisk.

wy2.PNG
Tabela results kopia.jpg

nvidia up 22% in 10 days to ATH

Nv 2 16-Oct-2023.PNG

16-Nov-2023. Nvidia +21.8% in 10 days to ATH Nvidia stock rose for the tenth consecutive session to a new all-time high on 14-Nov. This represents an increase of 21.8% (closing prices, 1-Nov to 14-Nov). Yesterday Nvidia had a first negative session (-1.55%). Nvidia is the top performer from the entire Mag7 club, counting since the publication of Q1 2023 earnings. Nominally, Nvidia has increased by 60.1% since May 24, 2023, and relative to the S&P500 by 50.7%. See Table 1, bottom panel. In second place is Meta with a rate of return since the publication of Q1 2023 results +58.9% nominally, and +47.9% relatively to the S&P500 (see table 1 and chart 1). Chart 2 shows Nvidia’s stock price since 2021. Recently, other companies have also been on a good streak: Microsoft: 9 positive days in a row (27-Oct to 8-Nov +10.8%), Meta: 8 positive days in a row (3-Nov to 14-Nov +8.2%), Amazon: 8 positive days in a row (27-Oct to 7-Nov +19.4%), S&P500: 8 positive days in a row (30-Oct to 8-Nov +6.5%).

Nvidia Tabela results 16-Oct-2023.jpg
Nv 1 16-Oct-2023.PNG

Is Nvidia expensive ?

nd2.jpg

4-Sep-2023. Is Nvidia expensive? Sure with MarketCap/Revenue almost at 19x However, based on its own valuation history and future revenues… the valuation didn't change much after Market Cap increased from USD 360 billion at the end of 2022 (MCap/Rev at 15x) to USD 1.2 trillion now (MCap/Rev at 18.7x) - with an average valuation for 2020-22 of 17.4x Revenues for the last 12 months (trailing twelve month) are USD 32.861 billion. This gives a MarketCap/Revenue ratio of as much as 36.7x But if, in the TTM calculation, we factor in Q3 2023 revenue (based on the company's guideline of $16.0 billion) - then the ratio drops to 28.0 - which is expensive even compared to Nvidia's own valuation history (average MarketCap / Revenue for 2020-2022 is "only” 18.4x). But when we calculate annual revenue based on the company's guideline for the subsequent quarter, the annualized revenue will hit $64.0 billion (based on the Q3 2024 guideline) and the MarketCap / Revenue ratio will drop to 18.7 - which is around the 2020-2022 average of 17.4x Practically, the only explanation for such an increase in revenues is the "Data Center" business segment, or AI in other words. Revenues in this segment are: Q3 2023 (exactly July 2022 - Nov 2022): USD 3.833 billion Q4 2023 (exactly November 2022 - January 2023): USD 3.616 billion Q1 2024 (exactly Feb 2023 - Apr 2023): USD 4.284 billion Q2 2024 (exactly May 2022 - July 2023): USD 10.323 billion Q3 2024 (exactly August 2022 - November 2023, my estimate): USD 12.723 billion From 3.6 to 12.7 in three quarters… amazing! Things like that don't happen…too often! So the main question is obvious… is this revenue growth sustainable? Or when will Nvidia hit the next air pocket or when will customers realize they ordered too many GPUs? Partial answers to such questions were given during the Q2 conference call, but more on that in the next post...

nd1.jpg
nd3.jpg

Nvidia AI & acc. computing

nvidia 1.PNG

4-Sep-2023. Nvidia - part 2. AI has an impact on the entire stock market and may extend the stock market cycle/further advance of equity indices. Based on the Nvidia’s Q2 conference call, it can be stated: - this is not a one-time leap related to AI, but "a new computing era has begun" and the industry is undergoing "a platform shift", - and it all boils down to two things: accelerated computing and generative AI. Vivek Arya, Bank of America Merrill Lynch – Analyst: “(…) Just give us your sense of how sustainable is this demand as we look over the next one to two years (…) how many servers are already AI accelerated? Where is that going? So, just give us some confidence that the growth that you are seeing is sustainable into the next one to two years.” Jensen Huang, CEO: “There's about $1 trillion worth of data centers, call it, a quarter of trillion dollars of -- of capital spend each year. You're seeing the data centers around the world are taking that capital spend and focusing it on the two most important trends of computing today, accelerated computing and generative AI. And so, I think this is not a -- this is not a -- a near-term thing. This is a -- a long-term industry transition, and we're seeing these two platform shifts happening at the same time.” Joe Moore, Morgan Stanley – Analyst: “(…) how much-unfulfilled demand do you think there is?” CEO: “(…) we have excellent visibility through the year and into next year. The demand -- the easiest way to think about the demand is the world is transitioning from general-purpose computing to accelerated computing. (…) The best way for companies to increase their throughput, improve their energy efficiency, improve their cost efficiency, is to divert their capital budget to accelerated computing and generative AI.” Toshi Hari, Goldman Sachs – Analyst: “(…) given your position as the key enabler of AI (…), I'm curious how confident you are that there will be enough applications or use cases for your customers to generate a reasonable return on their investments. I guess I asked the question because there is a concern out there that, you know, there could be a bit of a pause in your -- in your demand profile in the outyears.” CEO: “Toshi, I'm reluctant to -- to guess about the future (…) Using general-purpose computing at scale is no longer the best way to go forward. It's too costly, it's too expensive, and the performance of the applications are too slow, right? And finally, the world has a new way of doing it. It's called accelerated computing. And what kicked it into turbocharge is generative AI.”

Nvidia Q4 2023 preview

Nvidia PNG.png

20-Feb-2024. The entire investment world now depends on Nvidia's tomorrow earnings... ... and it's not even the largest company in the world (yet) 😊 Let's check the data… Wall Street expects revenues of $20.41 billion, which is sequentially +12.7% more than the previous quarter. See Figure 1. But year on year it will be +237.3%! The company itself provided guidance of $20.0 billion, +/- 2% (Figure 2). Wall Street also expects revenues to be exactly on the company's upper band. Not very ambitious… In the previous three quarters, the company beat the consensus by 11.9%, 22.4% and 10.3% respectively - see Figure 1. But the most important thing will, of course, be the increase in revenues in Data Centers (AI is mainly there). Wall Street expects $17.2 billion, or +18.6% sequentially and +375.87% YoY. See Figure 3. According to the consensus, revenues in Data Centers will increase by another 40% to $24.1 billion over the next 4 quarters.

FEB 20 Nvidia1.PNG
FEB 20 Nvidia2.PNG
FEB 20 Nvidia3.PNG

Nvidia Q4 2023 review

Nvidia PNG 2.png

22-Feb-2024. Nvidia Q4 2024 Earnings Review When Nvidia published its results for the quarter ending January 31, 2023, it beat Wall Street's revenue expectations by only 0.5%. Back then, revenues amounted to only $6.05 billion and dropped year-on-year by 20.8% (yes, that's the correct number, they dropped by over 20%). Fast forward a year to the current quarter ending January 31, 2024 and Nvidia beat market expectations by 8.3% (the smallest beat in 3 quarters - see Figure 1) delivering revenues of $22.10 billion - which means an increase of 22.0% sequentially and 265% year on year (and yes, this is also the correct number – see Figure 2). What does a year mean in the AI industry… The last year on the AI market was best summed up by Jensen Huang, founder and CEO of NVIDIA: “Accelerated computing and generative AI have hit the tipping point. Demand is surging worldwide across companies, industries and nations.” Exactly across: (1) companies, (2) industries, and (3) nations (so-called sovereign AI). Well, we can say that everyone is already investing in AI. Collete Cress, CFO during the earnings call: “ Countries around the world are investing in AI infrastructure to support the building of large language models in their own language, on domestic data, and in support of their local research and enterprise ecosystems.” However, the Data Centers business segment is responsible for as much as 92% of the year-on-year revenue growth - see Figure 3. The NVIDIA Data Center platform is focused on accelerating the most compute-intensive workloads, such as AI, data analytics, graphics and scientific computing. Jensen Huang, CEO: “Our Data Center platform is powered by increasingly diverse drivers — demand for data processing, training and inference from large cloud-service providers and GPU-specialized ones, as well as from enterprise software and consumer internet companies. Vertical industries — led by auto, financial services and healthcare — are now at a multibillion-dollar level”. Figure 4 shows the growth in revenues in this segment and the consensus of analysts' estimates for 2024-2025 (both before the publication of the results and after the upward revision made by analysts after the publication of the financial results).

Nvidia 1.PNG
Nvidia 2.PNG
Nvidia 3.png
Nvidia 4.PNG
Nvidia PNG 3.png

22-Feb-2024. Nvidia Q4 2024 Earnings Call Key Takeaways. CFO on demand for next generation products: “We expect our next generation products to be supply constrained as demand far exceeds supply.” Some color on AI revenue: “We estimate in the past year approximately 40% of data center revenue was for AI inference. (…) in the fourth quarter, large cloud providers represented more than half of our data center revenue”. On China: “Although we have not received licenses from the US government to ship restricted products to China, we have started shipping alternatives that don't require a license for the China market. China represented a mid single digit percentage of our data center revenue in Q4, and we expect it to stay in a similar range in the first quarter”. On new stream of revenues: “We also made great progress with our software and services offerings, which reached an annualized revenue run rate of $1 billion.“ CEO on revenue growth in 2024, 2025 and beyond: “Yeah, well, we guide one quarter at a time, but fundamentally, the conditions are excellent for continued growth. Calendar 24 to calendar 25 and beyond. And let me tell you why. We're at the beginning of two industry wide transitions, and both of them are industry wide. The first one is a transition from general to accelerated computing. General purpose computing, as you know, is starting to run out of steam. (…) There's just no reason to update with more CPUs when you can't fundamentally and dramatically enhance its throughput like you used to. And so you have to accelerate everything. This is what Nvidia has been pioneering for some time. And with accelerated computing, you can dramatically improve your energy efficiency, you can dramatically improve your cost in data processing by 20 to one, huge numbers. And of course, the speed, that speed is so incredible that we enabled a second industry wide transition called generative AI. (…) We believe these two trends will drive a doubling of the world's data center infrastructure installed base in the next five years and will represent an annual market opportunity in the hundreds of billions”.

CiscoNvidia

Nvidia vs Cisco Systems

Cisco bubble.png

25-Feb-2024. What does a real bubble look like? Try Cisco Systems Figure 1 shows the Price to Sales Ratio for Cisco Systems. In the 1990s, the company provided Internet infrastructure, just as Nvidia today provides computing infrastructure for artificial intelligence models. In the 1990s, Cisco was hailed as the King of the Internet. On March 27, 2000, at the peak of its stock price, Cisco was valued at 63 times sales and was then the largest company in the world by market cap, overtaking Microsoft. Figure 2 shows the Price to Sales ratio for both Cisco and Nvidia. As of February 23, 2024, Price to Sales for Nvidia is 31.9 (however, based on trailing sales). Because the company is rapidly increasing revenues, the actual Price to Sales is only 20 (see Figure 3, blue line). Nvidia has had 3 big business and valuation expansions in recent years (Figure 3): 1) Since 2016 due to the Bitcoin mining craze (Nvidia's GPUs were really popular for mining Bitcoin and Ethereum), 2) From 2020 due to the pandemic (Nvidia's GPUs supported remote work, gaming and covid-19 research), 3) From November 2023 due to the artificial intelligence boom (Nvidia's GPUs are essential for AI model training). Do we have a real bubble in Nvidia's valuation? Not necessary, if it is, it's more of a "baby bubble". Key takeaway: since 2020, the valuation has been stable around 18 times sales - see Figure 4 (Figure 5 shows more details about the company's market capitalization and annualized sales).

Cisco1.PNG
Cisco2.PNG
Cisco3 ver2.PNG
Cisco4.PNG
Cisco5.PNG

Nvidia valuation check

Nvidia March19 3D.png

21-Apr-2024. Nvidia – valuation check Nvidia fell by over 10% on Friday, and since the March 25 All-Time-High it is already down 19.8% (at closing prices). According to intraday prices, Nvidia has already fallen 21.77% (from the intraday high of $ 974 on March 8, 2024). Let's check how the company looks from a fundamental perspective, to simplify let’s have a look at sales growth. Figure 1 shows Wall Street's expectations for revenue growth: 1) Immediately before the earnings were published on February 22, 2024, 2) Immediately after the publication of these earnings, and 3) as of April 19, 2024. Current expectations are even higher than those after the publication of the results - analysts are constantly raising their expectations regarding revenue growth. That's good! Figure 2 shows Nvidia's market cap against revenues. The company's rapidly growing market cap goes hand in hand with strong revenue growth. Figure 3 shows the same relationship as the ratio (price to sales). As of April 19, the ratio dropped to 19.6 - and if we take the revenue expected by Wall Street in the next quarter (the company will publish its guidance on May 22, 2024) - the ratio drops to 17.8 - which is below the average for 2020-2023. Figure 4 shows the Nvidia stock price with the earnings release dates plotted. All in all, nothing to worry about business growth and Nvidia's valuation according to the Price to Sales ratio. As a reminder, the Price to Sales at the peak of the Cisco System stock price on March 25, 2000 was 63 - see Figure 5.

Nvidia March19.PNG
Nvidia March19 2.PNG
Nvidia March19 3.PNG
Nvidia March19 4.PNG
Nvidia March19 5.PNG

Nvidia's 20% drawdown

Nvidia April22 3D.png
Nvidia April22 1.png
Nvidia April22 3.png

22-Apr-2024. Is recent Nvidia’s 20% drawdown a big deal? If we look at history, a 20% drawdown is not a big deal... unfortunately. Figure 1 shows drawdowns on the Nvidia stock since 1999. Another example would be Cisco Systems in the 1990s - see Figure 2. On the way to the top in 2000, we had several drawdowns much larger than 20%. But there is also an interesting aspect in the case of Nvidia, looking at the price since 2016 - see Figure 3. Since 2016, we have experienced 3 strong growth waves and two over 50% drawdowns related to: (1) Bitcoin mining craze 2016-2018, (2) pandemic and gaming frenzy of 2020-2021, and (3) AI in 2022 – 2024. During the transition from (1) to (2) and from (2) to (3), Nvidia experienced revenue shortfalls ("air pockets") related to prior market saturation, which correlate with large drawdowns - see Figure 4. It can be assumed that, to a large extent, the target drawdown size this time may depend on the fact whether we are going to see another "air pocket" in the company's business... Nvidia reports its earnings on May 22 this year.

Nvidia April22 2.png
Nvidia April22 4.png

Nvidia's consensus change

Nvidia 11May 3D.png

11-May-2024. Nvidia - Wall Street Revenue Estimate Change Nvidia will release earnings on May 22 after the close of trading. This may be the second most important event in May (after the publication of the US CPI for April on May 15). Wall Street expects revenues to increase in Q1 2025 (quarter ending April 30, 2024) to $24.07 billion (which means +235% YoY, or +$16.88 billion). Let's check how the revenue consensus has changed recently. See Figure 1. While analysts significantly increased their estimates immediately after the publication of results for Q42024 (quarter ending January 31, 2024), in the next two months (from February 24 to April 19) the consensus increased only by +0.4% to +4.8 % - see the lower table in Figure 1. The last change between April 19 and May 8 is cosmetic. As a reminder, NVIDIA's outlook for the first quarter of fiscal 2025 with regards to revenue is $24.0 billion, plus or minus 2%. In previous quarters, the company easily beat its guidance. So by how much does a company have to beat its own outlook for the stock price to react positively this time?

Nvidia 11May.PNG

Nvidia Q1 2024 preview

Nvidia 11May 3D.png

22-May-2024. Will Nvidia beat all expectations once again? In each of its last five consecutive quarters Nvidia has beaten EPS and Sales estimates plus also raised guidance for the next quarter. Will it be the same this time? Wall Steet expects revenues of USD 24.69 billion and this forecast has increased by 2.6% in the last two weeks - see Figure 1. On May 8 this year the consensus revenue amounted to USD 24.07 billion (see the table at the bottom of the chart). The forecast for the next quarter (Nvidia will provide guidance for the next quarter) is USD 26.82 billion (an increase of only 0.8% since May 8). Wall Street expects earnings of $5.65 per share (adjusted (non-GAAP) diluted EPS). More of my analyzes about Nvidia at this link: https://jamkaglobal.com/mag8#mag8

NVDA 22May.PNG

Nvidia Q1 2024 review

Nvidia 3D 1.png
NVDA 1.PNG
NVDA 3.png
NVDA 5.PNG

24-May-2024. Nvidia Q1 Earnings Review Nvidia once again beat earnings expectations in fine style (see Figure 1). The current Wall Street consensus for future revenue, two days after the earnings release is up approximately 5-10% compared to the consensus immediately before the May 22 earnings release - see Figure 2. But the most important issue for investors remains the question of further revenue growth. According to Market Platform kind of revenues, the company's sales are split in 5 segments, but as much as 87% of sales are from the Data Centers segment. Interestingly, Data Centers segment is responsible for 97% of YoY sales growth, and for 106% of quarter-to-quarter sales growth. See Figure 3 and 4. Approximately 45% of sales in the Data Centers segment, or approximately $10.2 billion per quarter, are sales to 4 companies: Amazon, Alphabet, Meta and Microsoft (so-called hyperscalers). CFO commentary: “Data Center revenue of $22.6 billion was a record, up 23% sequentially and up 427% year-on-year, driven by continued strong demand for the NVIDIA Hopper GPU computing platform. (…) Strong sequential data center growth was driven by all customer types, led by enterprise and consumer internet companies. Large cloud providers continue to drive strong growth as they deploy and ramp NVIDIA AI infrastructure at scale and represented the mid-40s as a percentage of our Data Center revenue.” In a sense, we are dealing with a virtuous cycle when more advanced AI models need more computing power, and only better models can win this race. In this respect, the product cycle only drives Nvidia's sales when subsequent chip versions are even faster. The second trend is to expand the market beyond Hyperscalers, including Sovereign AI, but also other industries such as carmakers, biotechnology and health-care companies. Colette Kress on more demand for AI compute: „As generative AI makes its way into more consumer Internet applications, we expect to see continued growth opportunities as inference scales both with model complexity as well as with the number of users and number of queries per user, driving much more demand for AI compute. In our trailing four quarters, we estimate that inference drove about 40% of our Data Center revenue. Both training and inference are growing significantly.” On Sovereign AI demand: “Data Center revenue continues to diversify as countries around the world invest in Sovereign AI. Sovereign AI refers to a nation's capabilities to produce artificial intelligence using its own infrastructure, data, workforce and business networks. Nations are building up domestic computing capacity through various models. Some are procuring and operating Sovereign AI clouds in collaboration with state-owned telecommunication providers or utilities. Others are sponsoring local cloud partners to provide a shared AI computing platform for public and private sector use.” “we believe Sovereign AI revenue can approach the high single-digit billions this year. The importance of AI has caught the attention of every nation”. Jensen Huang on demand on AI training and inference (Training is the process of teaching an AI model how to perform a given task. Inference is the AI model in action, producing predictions or conclusions without human intervention): “Strong and accelerated demand -- accelerating demand for generative AI training and inference on Hopper platform propels our Data Center growth. Training continues to scale as models learn to be multimodal, understanding text, speech, images, video and 3D and learn to reason and plan.” “The demand for GPUs in all the data centers is incredible. We're racing every single day. And the reason for that is because applications like ChatGPT and GPT-4o, and now it's going to be multi-modality and Gemini and its ramp and Anthropic and all of the work that's being done at all the CSPs are consuming every GPU that's out there.” On startups demand: “There's also a long line of generative AI startups, some 15,000, 20,000 startups that in all different fields from multimedia to digital characters” “the demand, I think, is really, really high and it outstrips our supply. (…) Longer term, we're completely redesigning how computers work. And this is a platform shift. Of course, it's been compared to other platform shifts in the past. But time will clearly tell that this is much, much more profound than previous platform shifts. And the reason for that is because the computer is no longer an instruction-driven only computer. It's an intention-understanding computer.” Nvidia is quickly introducing new faster products, for example in the field of Data Center GPUs: H100 Tensor Core GPU, then H200 Tensor Core GPU, and the next one is GB200 NVL72. For example, Tesla has already purchased 35,000 H100s, Jensen Huang: „Enterprises drove strong sequential growth in Data Center this quarter. We supported Tesla's expansion of their training AI cluster to 35,000 H100 GPUs. Their use of NVIDIA AI infrastructure paved the way for the breakthrough performance of FSD Version 12, their latest autonomous driving software based on Vision.” The H200 boosts inference speed by up to 2X compared to H100 GPUs when handling LLMs like Llama2. H200 reduces also TCO (total cost of ownership) by 50% and energy use by 50% – see Figure 5. GB200 NVL72 delivers 30X faster real-time trillion-parameter LLM inference and 4X faster LLM training – see Figure 6.

NVDA 2.PNG
NVDA 4.png
NVDA 6.PNG

Nvidia valuation check

Nvidia 3D 3.png

26-May-2024. Is Nvidia stock already expensive? The bad news is that, unfortunately, yes. At least to its own valuation history for the last 4+ years. At a price of $1064.69, this is already the 88th percentile of the valuation from 2020-2024 according to the price to sales ratio. In other words, only 12% of the time during this period was Nvidia more expensive. Below are some valuation points: - at the median valuation point, the price should be $815 (-23.5% from today's price) - at 75th percentile $952 (-10.9% from today's price) - at 90th percentile $1,095 (+2.9% from today's price) - at 95th percentile $1,157 (+8.7% from today's price) - at 100th percentile $1,348 (+26.6% from today's price) - at 25th percentile $719 (-32.5% from today's price) To calculate the price-to-sales ratio, I used the annualized revenues from the next quarter (company's guidance). This approach reflects well the rapidly growing revenues. See Figure 1. Each quarter is shown separately. Figure 2 shows Nividia's stock price on a logarithmic scale. A few weeks ago, investors had a moment of doubt and at the session on April 19, they sold Nvidia with a maximum decline on that day of even -11% at a price of $756.1. To date, the price has increased by over 40%. Figure 3 shows how Nvidia's stock price reacted relative to the S&P500 after the earnings release. Each of the last 6 quarters has yielded a higher return than the S&P500. After the publication of the last results on May 22, we are now 12.2% relatively higher than the S&P500. Finally, there is also good "news"... first, that in the short term, valuations do not have a major impact on the company's share price, and second, it can be expected with a high degree of probability that the bull market in Nvidia shares should last until the end of the bull market on the entire market (as was the case, for example, with Cisco Systems in the 1990s). This does not mean that significant corrections are not possible (e.g. in April this year, when the drawdown on Nvidia’s shares was 22.4% (intraday) and 19.8% at closing prices).

NVDA valuation 1.PNG
NVDA valuation 2.PNG
NVDA valuation 3.PNG

Nvidia inflation is good!

Nvid Taiwan 3D.png
Nvid 01.png

3-Jun-2024. Inflation is good. While economies, central banks and markets today have problems with inflation... Nvidia makes money from inflation... This is of course all about "computation inflation" – see Figure 1. NVIDIA CEO Jensen Huang at COMPUTEX 2024, Taiwan, June 2, 2024: “If the data that is that we need to process continues to scale exponentially but performance does not - we will experience computation inflation and in fact we're seeing that right now as we speak. The amount of data center power that's used all over the world is growing quite substantially, the cost of computing is growing, we are seeing computation inflation. This of course cannot continue, the data is going to continue to increase exponentially and CPU performance scaling will never return. There is a better way. For almost two decades now we've been working on accelerated Computing Cuda augments a CPU, offloads and accelerates the work that a specialized processor can do much better, in fact the performance is so extraordinary that it is very clear now as CPU scaling has slowed and event substantially stopped. We should accelerate everything I predict that every application that is processing intensive will be accelerated and surely every data center will be accelerated the near future.” But how to fight that inflation? It’s simple: The more you buy the more you save! – see Figure 2. “We could accelerate what used to take a 100 units of time down to one unit of time.” “We add a GPU a $500 to a $1,000 PC and the performance increases tremendously. We do this in a data center, a billion dollar data center, we add $500 million worth of GPUs and all of a sudden it becomes an AI Factory. This is happening all over the world today. Well the savings are quite extraordinary.. 1)you're getting 60 times performance per dollar 2)a 100 times speed up you only increase your power by 3x 3)100 times speed up you only increase your cost by 1.5x The savings are incredible. The savings are measured in dollars, it is very clear that many companies spend hundreds of millions of dollars processing data in the cloud. That's the reason why you've heard me say the more you buy the more you save and now I've shown you the mathematics, it is not accurate but it is correct, okay that's called CEO math. CEO math is not accurate but it is correct: the more you buy the more you save.”

Nvid 02.png

Nvidia - this is Blackwell

Blackwell 3d.png
Blackwell 01.png

16-Jun-2024. Ladies and gentlemen, this is Blackwell. Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang’s Keynote at COMPUTEX 2024 was fascinating. Below are selected excerpts about the world's most powerful AI chip: Nvidia's Blackwell. Jensen Huang (Figure 1): “Ladies and gentlemen, this is Blackwell. Blackwell is in production. Incredible amounts of technology.” Blackwell-architecture GPUs pack 208 billion transistors and are manufactured using a custom-built TSMC 4NP process. All Blackwell products feature two reticle-limited dies connected by a 10 terabytes per second (TB/s) chip-to-chip interconnect in a unified single GPU. Jensen Huang (Figure 2): “This is our production board. This is the most complex, highest performance computer the world's ever made. This is the Grace CPU. And these are, you can see each one of these Blackwell dies, two of them connected together. You see that it is the largest die, the largest chip the world makes. And then we connect two of them together with a ten terabyte per second link.” Figure 3: “And the performance is incredible. Take a look at this. So, you see, you see, the computational, the FLOPs, the AI FLOPs, for each generation has increased by a thousand times in eight years. Moore's law in eight years is something along the lines of, oh, I don't know, maybe 40, 60. And in the last eight years, Moore's law has gone a lot, lot less. And so just to compare, even Moore's Law as best of times compared to what Blackwell could do.” Figure 4: “And whenever we bring the computation high, the thing that happens is the cost goes down. (…) the energy used to train a GPT-4, 2 trillion parameter, 8 trillion tokens (…) has gone down by 350 times. Well, Pascal would have taken 1,000 gigawatt hours. (…) we've now taken with Blackwell what used to be 1,000 gigawatt hours to three, an incredible advance, three gigawatt hours.” From 17,000 joules (of energy) per token to just 0,4 joules per token! Chat GPT-4 uses about 3 tokens to generate one word. Jensen Huang: “Our token generation performance has made it possible for us to drive the energy down by 45,000 times, 17,000 joules per token. That was Pascal 17,000 joules. It's kind of like two light bulbs running for two days. It would take two light bulbs running for two days. Amounts of energy, 200W running for two days to generate one token of GPT-4. It takes about three tokens to generate one word. And so the amount of energy used necessary for Pascal to generate GPT-4 and have a ChatGPT experience with you was practically impossible. But now we only use 0.4 joules per token, and we can generate tokens at incredible rates and very little energy.” However, the Blackwell is not big enough for AI compute! Jensen Huang (Figure 5): “Okay, so Blackwell is just an enormous leap. Well, even so, it's not big enough. And so we have to build even larger machines. And so the way that we build it is called DGX.” DGX Blackwell (GB200 NVL72) connects 36 Grace CPUs and 72 Blackwell GPUs in a rack-scale design. The GB200 NVL72 is a liquid-cooled, rack-scale solution that boasts a 72-GPU NVLink domain that acts as a single massive GPU. This “massive single GPU” is quite big – see Figure 6. Yet, what’s amazing.. it’s still not enough for AI compute… but this is a story for another post… Jensen Huang: “And even this is not big enough, even this is not big enough for an AI factory. So we have to connect it all together with very high speed networking.”

Blackwell 02.png
Blackwell 03.png
Blackwell 04.png
Blackwell 05.png
Blackwell 06.png

Nvidia valuation check

NVDA 3DD.png

19-Jun-2024. Nvidia – already expensive? The wealth of the Nvidia’s CEO increased by $3.9 billion only during yesterday's session (this is an increase in the value of Nvidia shares held by Jensen Huang), and by as much as $74.9 billion since the beginning of the year. Investors have nothing to complain about... because only during yesterday's session the value of their Nvidia shares increased by $113.3 billion, and since the beginning of the year... drum roll please... by $2.11 trillion. So is Nvidia already expensive? Price to sale, based on the sum of revenues from the preceding 12 months (TTM), is 41.8x. At the peak of market valuation in March 2000, Cisco Systems achieved a Price to Sales of 63.2x - see Figure 1. But the Nvidia's revenues are growing rapidly. TTM currently amounts to $79.77 billion. But based on the company's guidance (next quarter annualized company's guidance), they already amount to $112.00 billion - see Figure 2. Price to Sales drops to 29.8x. Wall Street continues to raise its own estimates of Nvidia's future revenues (see Figure 3) and the current forecast for 4 subsequent quarters is $130.67 billion - thus the Price to Sales drops to 25.5x. Wall Street forecasts revenues in the another 4 subsequent quarters (from the 5th to the 8th quarter, i.e. from May 2025 to April 2026) at the level of $161.34 billion - which reduces the Price to Sales ratio to (only) 20.7x. Summary in Figure 4.

NVDA 01.PNG
NVDA 02.PNG
NVDA 03.PNG

Nvidia's drawdowns

NVDA drawdowns 3DD.png

22-Jun-2024. How big Nvidia's drawdown is attractive? After two down sessions, Nvidia is down 6.65% since its last ATH (based on daily closing prices). This is the biggest drop since April when we had a drawdown of 19.79%, ending with a strong note: a 10% price drop in one day... on April 19. Since the bottom in October 2022, we have so far had three large drawdowns of around 20%, and with such large drawdowns, the entire market (S&P500) joined the declines at the same time - see Figure 1. Generally, it can be said that during this period, Nvidia did not have any major declines above 10% unless the entire market fell at the same time. The current Nvidia drawdown of 6.65% did not result in declines on the S&P500 - where the drawdown is only 0.41%. Let's check what drawdowns we faced in the case of Cisco Systems in the 1990s. See Figure 2. From the bottom of 1994 ($0.77), the price of Cisco rose to the top in 2000 ($56.85) by 73 times! At the same time, the S&P500 increased only 3.4 times. On the way to the top, Cisco had 5 drawdowns above 20% (the largest were 51%, 38%, 37%, 29%, 26%). However, the size of the drawdown was less related to the decline of the entire market (S&P500). Only the last large drawdown in 1998 can be clearly linked to the decline of the broad market (Cisco -37%, S&P500 -19%). Interestingly, the declines also ended with a strong one-day decline (on August 31, 1998, the S&P500 fell 6.8%, marking the bottom of the correction). Cisco fell 13.5% on that day (although it marked the bottom of its own correction only on October 7, 1998). But similarly in the case of Cisco... the end of the correction was associated with a strong accent: 3 consecutive days of declines of -13%, -4% and -5%. In total 21%. From then until 2000 top, Cisco's share price increased by 630%! Figure 3 compares Nvidia and S&P500 drawdowns, and Figure 4 similarly for Cisco Systems. In the case of Nvidia, historical declines above 50% are nothing out of the ordinary. However, after a decline of 89% in 2002, Cisco needed as many as 19 years to set another ATH. In the case of Nvidia, the size of the drawdown may be influenced (in the future) by the scale of the slowdown in Nvidia's revenue growth, as well as how such a slowdown in growth, or even a possible decline in revenues, will be received by the market.

NVDA drawdowns 001.png
NVDA drawdowns 002.png
NVDA drawdowns 003a.png
NVDA drawdowns 004.png

Tesla Q2 2023 review

Tesla Q2 2023 001.jpeg

23-Jul-2023. This year, Tesla's share price is up more than 170%. However, after the publication of Q2 results (July 19, 2023), Tesla fell 9.7%, similarly after the publication of Q1 results (April 19), the decline was also 9.7%. One of the main reasons of negative market reaction (within the financial results) is the declining gross margin (sales revenue minus costs of products sold), which in Q1 2022 amounted to 29.1% - and now is only 18.2%. The main cause is the falling demand for cars and the rising cost of debt financing consumer purchases - which triggers Tesla to cut sales prices and worsen its sales mix. From March 2022, interest rate increases in the US began, which coincides perfectly with the falling gross margin. Elon Musk on price cuts: “So when interest rates rise dramatically, we actually have to reduce the price of the car because the interest payments increase the price of the car. And this is, at least up until recently, it was, I believe, the sharpest interest rate rise in history.” Zach Kirkhorn, CFO: “Variability around average selling prices goes back to Elon’s point. We don't control interest rates. We don't control macro consumer sentiment. But we have an obligation to be responsive to that to ensure that we're matching supply and demand and keeping things balanced. And so, this is how we're managing the next handful of quarters. Soon enough, these quarters will be behind us.” Tesla is a growth company (in Q2 TTM revenues increase YoY by 40%) and there is a rather small chance that it will "fall out" of the club of "The Magnificent Seven" (MSFT, AAPL, NVDA, TSLA, GOOGL, META, AMZN), but from the fundamental point of view, it is worth watching how Tesla will cope with falling margins and a difficult market environment for the automotive industry.

Tesla Q2 2023 002.jpeg
Tesla Q2 2023 003.jpeg
Tesla Q2 2023 004.jpeg

Tesla Q3 2023 preview

tesla 3.PNG

18-Oct-2023. Tesla. Q3 2023 results. Tesla will release Q3 2023 financial results today after the market close. The 3 previous releases in a row meant a price movement on the next day of 9-10% relative to the S&P500 (Chart 1). Tesla's stock behaved interestingly after the publication of the Q1 2023 results: the next day it fell 9%, and then during the quarter it increased by over 50% relative to the S&P500 (Chart 1). In the current quarter, after the publication of Q2 2023 results, Tesla's price performed the worst of all "Mag7" stocks (Chart 2). What will investors pay special attention to in Q3 2023 results: - price reductions for Model 3 and Model Y - delayed rollout of Cybertruck - pressure on margins and if the trough in the margin is possible this quarter - expected revenues: USD 24.2 billion, adjusted EPS: USD 0.74, adjusted net income: USD 2.56 billion.

tesla 2.PNG
tesla 1.PNG

Tesla Q3 2023 review

tesla2.PNG

19-Oct-2023. Tesla. Q3 2023 results. Part 1. Key takeaways: 1) Formally, Tesla published results below expectations, missing on top-line, margins, bottom-line and deliveries: Revenues $23.35 billion (vs expected $24.06 billion) Gross margin 17.9% (vs 18.0% expected) Gross margin ex-regulatory credits 16.3% (vs 17.7% expected) Adjusted EPS $0.66 (vs $0.74 expected) Total deliveries (published a few days earlier) 435.1k in Q3 (vs 456.7k expected) 2) The high interest rate environment “is killing” demand, hence price cuts and falling margins. It is difficult to expect changes here until rates drop. Of course, Tesla reduces costs etc. to adapt to such a situation, 3) Sentiment towards the company may improve at the end of the year due to the launch of Cybertruck production in Texas. While the potential demand is huge (e.g. there are currently above 1 million people who have reserved the car), achieving high and profitable production will take many months and, in general, according to Elon Musk, it is a very big challenge.

tesla3.PNG
tesla1 ss.PNG
tesla4.PNG

19-Oct-2023. Tesla. Q3 2023 results. Part 2. Below are selected statements from the results conference. Elon Musk on Cybertruck: “It is going to require immense work to reach volume production and be cash flow positive at a price that people can afford (…) prototypes are easy, production is hard (…) But this difficulty going from a prototype to volume production is like 10,000% harder to get to volume production than to make the prototype in the first place. And then it is even harder than that to reach positive cash flow (…) I just want to temper expectations for Cybertruck (…) it will take, I don't know, a year to 18 months before it is a significant positive cash flow contributor (…) the demand is off the charts. We have over 1 million people who have reserved the car (…) we need to make it at a price that people can afford, insanely difficult things.” On Cybertruck yearly output: “I think we'll end up with roughly 0.25 million Cybertrucks a year, but we're not -- I don't think we're going to reach that output rate next year (…) I think we'll probably reach it sometime in 2025.” On complexity of Cybertruck: “(…) we dug our own grave with the Cybertruck. You know, nobody – in general, probably nobody digs a grave better than themselves. And so, it is -- Cybertruck's one of those special products that comes along only once in a long while. And special products that come along once in a long while are just incredibly difficult to bring to market to reach volume, to be prosperous. It's fundamental to the nature of the newness.” Elon Musk on high interest rates: “I am worried about the high interest rate environment that we're in. I just can't emphasize this enough, that the vast majority of people buying a car is about the monthly payment (…) If interest rates remain high or if they go even higher, it's that much harder for people to buy the car. They simply can't afford it (…). A lot of -- a large number of people are living paycheck to paycheck.” On whether Tesla can postpone building a new factory in Mexico due to weak economy/demand? „We're definitely making the factory in Mexico (…) The question is really just one of timing. And there's going to be a broken record on the interest front. It's just the interest rates have to come down. Like if interest rates keep rising, you just fundamentally reduce affordability. It is just the same as increasing the price of the car. So, I just don't have visibility into -- if you can tell me what the interest rates are, I can tell you when we should build the factory (…). But I am still somewhat scarred by 2009 when General Motors and Chrysler went bankrupt (…) So, I'm like -- I want to just -- I don't want to be going at top speed into uncertainty (…). If interest rates start coming down, we will accelerate.”

Tesla's reaction to Q3 2023 

tesla price 1 kopia.jpg

20-Oct-2023. Tesla. The second day after the Q3 2023 results. After two days: Tesla is down -12.65% S&P500 -2.10%. So Tesla relative to S&P500 is -10.55%.

tesla1.PNG
tesla5.PNG

19-Oct-2023. Tesla. The first day after the Q3 2023 result. Tesla is down -9.30% at market close. S&P500 is -0.85%. So Tesla relative to S&P500 is -8.45%. The chart shows how Tesla's price behaved relatively to the S&P500 after the earnings release for: Q4 2022, Q1 2023, Q2 2023 and Q3 2023.

Tesla Q4 2023 review

Tesla Q4.png

26-Jan-2024. Tesla. Q4 2023 results. Part 1. My key takeaways: 1) Q4 2023 was below expectations, but not to such an extent as after the results for Q3 2023. Tesla sold more cars in Q4 2023 than the market expected (485k vs 473k), which it announced at the beginning of January. Still, revenues were lower than market expectations ($25.17 billion vs expected $25.87 billion, Figure 1) due to lower average selling prices. Tesla is constantly lowering the sales prices of its models, which is a way to increase sales while the demand for cars is weakening. 2) Therefore, due to the cuts in selling prices, margins were supposed to be the most important point for Wall Street. And here Tesla delivered more than the market expected, but not on every margin. The gross margin was below market expectations (17.6% vs. expected 18.1%), but perhaps the most important margin, automotive gross margin excluding regulatory credits, turned out to be well above expectations (17.2% vs. expected 15.0%, Figure 2). Mainly because that Tesla was able to reduce the cost of production per vehicle, Figure 3. 3) But it was the outlook for 2024 that did the most damage: "In 2024, our vehicle volume growth rate may be notably lower than the growth rate achieved in 2023, as our teams work on the launch of the next-generation vehicle at Gigafactory Texas." This means that in 2024, the growth will be weak, but it will be compensated by a stronger sales in 2025 (in H2 2025, a new car model from the lower segment will be launched with a target sales volume of up to 500,000 per year). 4) Therefore, in 2024, there remains the sale of existing models and the Cybertruck (which is unlikely to achieve large production volumes soon). Yesterday the share price in the cash market reacted even stronger than in the after-hours trade (down 12.13% vs 6-8% in the after-hours trade) and it is similar to the previous 3 quarters: After the results for Q1 2023, Tesla's price fell on the 1st day on the cash market by 9.75% (S&P500 -0.60%), After the results for Q2 2023, Tesla's price fell by 9.74% on the 1st day (S&P500 -0.68%), After the results for Q3 2023, Tesla's price fell by 9.30% on the 1st day (S&P500 -0.85%).

Tesla Q4 1.png
Tesla Q4 2.PNG
Tesla Q4 3.PNG
Tesla 2024-2025.png

27-Jan-2024. Tesla Q4 2023 earnings review. Part 2. Figure 1 shows the current (so post analysts' revisions after the publication of Q4 2023 results) consensus revenues forecast for 2024-2025. Clearly, the world is not over for Tesla yet. On a YoY basis, revenues from Q3 2024 accelerate to approximately 20% YoY growth (quarter-on-quarter in Q2 2024 we have growth of +6.6% - then between 2.2% and 6.3% QoQ). If revenues are to grow by more than 20% (YoY) in Q3 2024, investors could try to front-run such growth in Q2…, ceteris paribus. Figure 2 shows how Tesla's price behaved relative to the S&P500 after the publication of the earnings (last 5 quarters). Max relative (to S&P500) drawdowns were: After Q1-2023: -12.5% After Q2-2023: -21.7% After Q3-2023: -15.3% After Q4-2023 to date: -12.3%. But to better assess the price behavior immediately after the publication of the results, one should also look at the price behavior in the previous quarter and immediately before the publication of the results (as can be seen in Figure 2, there are significant differences in this respect). Additionally, one also need to look at the size of beat/miss of the results and the size of “beat/miss” of the company's outlook/guidance. --- Elon Musk during the results conference about the margin and demand for Tesla cars: "If the interest rates come down quickly, I think margins will be good. And if they don't come down quickly, they won't be that good, yeah. It's always important to remember that the vast majority of people buying a car is about the monthly payment. It's not that people don't want -- we have tons of -- we have lots of people who want to buy our car but simply cannot afford it. (…) It's straightforward pretty. And there are no tricks around -- to get around this.” And about Cybertruck: “It's important to emphasize that this is very much a production-constrained situation, not a demand-constrained situation. And we you know, obviously, like, we could dramatically raise the price, but that -- that doesn't feel right to us to sort of, you know, gouge people for, you know, for early delivery, so. But really, the demand is off the hook. As long, as long as the price is affordable, I mean, I see us ultimately delivering on the order of a quarter million -- something like a quarter million Cybertrucks a year in North America, but maybe more, give or take, you know, roughly on that -- on that time frame.” The consensus expects Cybertruck production to reach 112k annual run-rate in Q4 2024 and 155k annual run-rate in Q4 2025.

Tesla Q4 part2 1.png
Tesla Q4 part2 2.PNG

Tesla Q1 2024 preview

Tesla Q124 3D.png

23-Apr-2024. Tesla Q1 2024 Earnings Preview Wall Street expects Q1 2024 revenue at $22.3 billion, representing a YoY decline of 4.4%, and sequentially (against Q4 2023) of 11.4%. Since the publication of the results for Q4 2023, analysts have significantly lowered their forecasts for Tesla - Figure 1, and the share price has fallen by over 30% since then (Figure 2). At the beginning of April, we also got data on deliveries and production in Q1 2024 – see Figure 3. Deliveries dropped by 20% QoQ (but there were several one-off events). Tesla's main problem: high interest rates that reduce demand (cars are usually bought on credit) and relatively high prices of EV cars (even less demand). What to pay special attention to in the Q1 2024 earnings: 1) Mainly EV demand and margins (price cuts), but also 2) Future growth driver like robotaxis 3) Full Self Driving (and recognition of deferred revenues) 4) Cybertruck demand, production etc. 5) And other things like Elon's compensation, workforce reductions, gigafactory expansion, mass-market vehicle.

Tesla Q124 1.PNG
Tesla Q124 3.PNG
Tesla Q124 2.PNG

Tesla Q1 2024 review

Tesla Q12024 3D.png

25-Apr-2024. Tesla Q1 2024 earnings review My key takeaways: 1) Q1 2024 was a terrible quarter, with revenues down 15.4% QoQ and 8.7% YoY. Mainly due to a drop in ASP (vehicle average selling price), but partly due to one-off events (like Giga Berlin production disruptions). Tesla showed negative free cash flow in Q1, mainly due to higher car production and lower deliveries, but also higher CAPEX. Q2 2024 should be much better. 2) To improve the situation, Tesla cut employment by 10% (The savings generated are expected to be well in excess of $1 billion on an annual run rate basis), and accelerates the introduction of a new cheap car model. It seems that the faster introduction of the new cheap model "saved" the company's share price. At least for a while. Elon Musk during earnings call: “We've updated our future vehicle lineup to accelerate the launch of new models ahead, previously mentioned start of production in the second half of 2025. So, we expect it to be more like the early 2025, if not late this year.” 3) Great emphasis during the earnings call is placed on the future fully autonomous version of FSD (full self-driving). This will "unlock" the true value of the company. But we don't know how long it will take. This could still be years away. Some analysts talk about the 2030s. But Tesla is well on its way to achieving this, and the latest FSD Version 12 is fully AI-based. Elon Musk: “I think Cathie Wood said it best. Like really, we should be thought of as an AI or robotics company. If you value Tesla as just like an auto company, you just have to -- fundamentally, it's just the wrong framework (…). So, I mean, if somebody doesn't believe Tesla is going to solve autonomy, I think they should not be an investor in the company.” “(…) the way to think of Tesla is almost entirely in terms of solving autonomy and being able to turn on that autonomy for a gigantic fleet. And I think it might be the biggest asset value appreciation history when that day happens when you can do unsupervised full self-driving.” 4) All in all, is all the worst already priced in the price? Doubtful, car demand will not rebound significantly until interest rates fall. But at least Tesla's post-earnings rebound of some 12% gives some hope. Yet the real test will be to defend the stock price level before the results were announced, i.e. USD 140-145 range. Figure 1 shows the revenues $bln and YoY%. Figure 2 shows Tesla’s margins. Figure 3 shows Tesla’s avergae cost of vehicle. Figure 4-6 show Tesla’s revenue segments (Automotive, Energy Generation & Storage, Services & Other).

Tesla Q12024 1.PNG
Tesla Q12024 2.PNG
Tesla Q12024 3.PNG
Tesla Q12024 4.PNG
Tesla Q12024 5.PNG
Tesla Q12024 6.PNG
bottom of page